ISO 9459-4:2013

Solar heating — Domestic water heating systems — Part 4: System performance characterization by means of component tests and computer simulation

ISO 9459-4:2013 specifies a method of evaluating the annual energy performance of solar water heaters using a combination of test results for component performance and a mathematical model to determine an annual load cycle task performance under specified weather and load conditions. The procedure is applicable to solar water heaters with integral backup or preheating into a conventional storage or instantaneous water heater and to integral collector storage water heaters. System operating requirements specified in ISO 9459-4:2013 are for the purpose of determining an annual performance rating for domestic water heaters. There are no product design or operation requirements in ISO 9459-4:2013.

Chauffage solaire — Systèmes de chauffage de l'eau sanitaire — Partie 4: Caractérisation de la performance des systèmes au moyen d'essais effectués sur les composants et par simulation sur ordinateur

General Information

• Status: Published
• Publication Date: 03-Feb-2013
• ICS: 27.160 - Solar energy engineering
• ICS: 97.100.99 - Heaters using other sources of energy
• Technical Committee: ISO/TC 180/SC 4 - Systems - Thermal performance, reliability and durability
• Drafting Committee: ISO/TC 180/SC 4 - Systems - Thermal performance, reliability and durability
• Current Stage: 9060 - Close of review
• Start Date: 02-Dec-2028

Standards Content (Sample)

INTERNATIONAL ISO
STANDARD 9459-4
First edition
2013-02-15

Solar heating — Domestic water heating
systems —
Part 4:
System performance characterization by
means of component tests and computer
simulation
Chauffage solaire — Systèmes de chauffage de l'eau sanitaire —
Partie 4: Caractérisation de la performance des systèmes au moyen
d'essais effectués sur les composants et par simulation sur ordinateur




Reference number
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
©
ISO 2013

---------------------- Page: 1 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)

COPYRIGHT PROTECTED DOCUMENT


©  ISO 2013
All rights reserved. Unless otherwise specified, no part of this publication may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means,
electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and microfilm, without permission in writing from either ISO at the address below or
ISO's member body in the country of the requester.
ISO copyright office
Case postale 56  CH-1211 Geneva 20
Tel. + 41 22 749 01 11
Fax + 41 22 749 09 47
E-mail [e-mail]
Web www.iso.org
Published in Switzerland

ii © ISO 2013 – All rights reserved

---------------------- Page: 2 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
Contents Page
Foreword . iv
0  Introduction . v
1  Scope . 1
2  Normative references . 1
3  Terms and definitions . 1
4  Symbols, units and nomenclature . 3
5  Application . 6
6  Test method . 7
6.1  Introduction . 7
6.2  Component testing . 7
6.3  Water heater configuration for modelling . 9
7  Performance evaluation . 10
7.1  Annual task performance . 10
7.2  Weather data . 10
7.3  Thermal energy loads . 11
7.4  Thermostat set temperature . 11
7.5  Cold water inlet temperature . 11
7.6  Pump circulation control . 11
7.7  Simulation deck setup for modelling thermal stratification in storage tanks . 12
7.8  Piping configuration for solar water heaters . 13
7.9  Controllers . 14
7.10  Energy consumed for freeze protection . 14
7.11  Over-temperature control . 15
7.12  Modelling gas storage water heaters . 15
7.13  Modelling instantaneous gas water heaters . 16
7.14  Presentation of results . 17
7.15  Extension of simulation model for new products . 19
Annex A (normative) Water heater parameters . 20
Annex B (normative) Storage vessel performance . 34
Annex C (normative) Integral collector storage unit test method . 37
Annex D (normative) Corrections for effect of hail guards on solar collector efficiency . 41
Annex E (normative) PV powered DC pumps in solar water heating systems . 43
Annex F (normative) Heat exchanger test methods . 50
Annex G (normative) Reference conditions for testing and performance prediction . 58
Annex H (informative) Example simulation models . 63
Annex I (informative) Guidelines for equipment suppliers . 67
Annex J (informative) Guidelines for Certification Bodies . 68
Bibliography . 70

© ISO 2013 – All rights reserved iii

---------------------- Page: 3 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
Foreword
ISO (the International Organization for Standardization) is a worldwide federation of national standards bodies
(ISO member bodies). The work of preparing International Standards is normally carried out through ISO
technical committees. Each member body interested in a subject for which a technical committee has been
established has the right to be represented on that committee. International organizations, governmental and
non-governmental, in liaison with ISO, also take part in the work. ISO collaborates closely with the
International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) on all matters of electrotechnical standardization.
International Standards are drafted in accordance with the rules given in the ISO/IEC Directives, Part 2.
The main task of technical committees is to prepare International Standards. Draft International Standards
adopted by the technical committees are circulated to the member bodies for voting. Publication as an
International Standard requires approval by at least 75 % of the member bodies casting a vote.
Attention is drawn to the possibility that some of the elements of this document may be the subject of patent
rights. ISO shall not be held responsible for identifying any or all such patent rights.
ISO 9459-4 was prepared by Technical Committee ISO/TC 180, Solar energy, Subcommittee SC 4,
Systems — Thermal performance, reliability and durability.
ISO 9459 consists of the following parts, under the general title Solar heating — Domestic water heating
systems:
 Part 1: Performance rating procedure using indoor test methods
 Part 2: Outdoor test methods for system performance characterization and yearly performance prediction
of solar-only systems
 Part 4: System performance characterization by means of component tests and computer simulation
 Part 5: System performance characterization by means of whole-system tests and computer simulation
iv © ISO 2013 – All rights reserved

---------------------- Page: 4 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
0 Introduction
ISO 9459 has been developed to help facilitate the international comparison of solar domestic water heating
systems. Because a generalized performance model which is applicable to all systems has not yet been
developed, it has not been possible to obtain an international consensus for one test method and one
standard set of test conditions. It has therefore been decided to promulgate the currently available simple test
methods while work continues to finalize the more broadly applicable procedures. The advantage of this
approach is that each part can proceed on its own.
0.1 General
ISO 9459 is divided into four parts within three broad categories, as described below.
0.2 Rating test
ISO 9459-1, Solar heating — Domestic water heating systems — Part 1: Performance rating procedure using
indoor test methods, involves testing for periods of one day for a standardized set of reference conditions. The
results, therefore, allow systems to be compared under identical solar, ambient and load conditions.
0.3 Black box correlation procedures
ISO 9459-2, Solar heating — Domestic water heating systems — Part 2: Outdoor test methods for system
performance characterization and yearly performance prediction of solar-only systems, is applicable to solar-
only systems and solar-preheat systems. The performance test for solar-only systems is a “black box”
procedure which produces a family of “input-output” characteristics for a system. The test results may be used
directly with daily mean values of local solar irradiation, ambient air temperature and cold water temperature
data to predict annual system performance.
0.4 Testing and computer simulation
ISO 9459-4, Solar heating — Domestic water heating systems — Part 4: System performance
characterization by means of component tests and computer simulation, a procedure for characterizing annual
system performance, uses measured component characteristics in a computer simulation program.
Procedures for characterizing the performance of system components other than collectors are also presented
in this part of ISO 9459. Procedures for characterizing the performance of collectors are given in other
International Standards.
ISO 9459-5, Solar heating — Domestic water heating systems — Part 5: System performance
characterization by means of whole-system tests and computer simulation, presents a procedure for dynamic
testing of complete systems to determine system parameters for use in the “Dynamic System Testing
Program”. This software has been validated on a range of systems; however, it is a proprietary product and
cannot be modified by the user. Implementation of the software requires training from a test facility
experienced with the application of the product. This model may be used with hourly values of local solar
irradiation, ambient air temperature and cold water temperature data to predict annual system performance.
The procedures defined in ISO 9459-2, ISO 9459-4 and ISO 9459-5 for predicting yearly performance allow
the output of a system to be determined for a range of climatic conditions.
The results of tests performed in accordance with ISO 9459-1 provide a rating for a standard day.
The results of tests performed in accordance with ISO 9459-2 permit performance predictions for a range of
system loads and operating conditions, but only for an evening draw-off.
© ISO 2013 – All rights reserved v

---------------------- Page: 5 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
0.5 Introduction to ISO 9459-4
ISO 9549-4 presents a procedure predicting the annual performance of a solar thermal system using a
numerical simulation programme. The parameters of the characterisation of the thermal behaviour of the key
components such as solar collector, store and controller are derived from physical tests of the components.
Because testing of the complete system as a whole is especially expensive and time consuming for system
families, this approach offers the opportunity to determine the annual performance of a family of systems with
limited effort.
NOTE A system family is characterised by a series of hot water systems that are identical with regard to their
construction and only differ in their collector and storage dimension. An identical construction is given if the set-up of the
system is similar (pipes, electrical pump, hydraulic connections, type but not mandatorily size of the heat exchanger), the
insulation concept is similar (material, thickness) and the collectors installed are from the same type.
Procedures exist for testing most solar thermal system components. Where they exist, they are referenced. In
case no standardised component test procedures are available appropriate procedures have to be used to
determine the thermal characteristics of the components.
The intention of this International Standard is to determine the thermal performance of the system. Therefore,
it is assumed that all key components (e.g., collectors, stores, heat exchangers, etc.) used in the system are
subjected to relevant durability tests (e.g., collector qualification tests, pressurization of the collector side of
the heat exchanger, etc.) before they are tested for thermal performance.
In order to ensure a proper operation of the entire system additional durability tests may be required of the
complete system to determine operation under extreme conditions such as freezing or overheating based on
corresponding standards.
The performance evaluation procedure defined in this International Standard has been designed to provide a
means of evaluating the annual task performance of heated water systems.
This International Standard sets out a method of evaluating the annual energy performance of heated water
systems using a combination of test results for component performance and a mathematical model to
determine an annual load cycle task performance. This International Standard defines a procedure for
evaluating the task performance of conventional electric and gas domestic water heaters so that the energy
savings of solar and heat pump water heaters can be evaluated relative to conventional water heaters
operated under the same annual task load.
The performance evaluations are based on modelling annual performance in a range of climatic conditions
using a simulation program. The chosen simulation program shall have flexibility and the capacity to model the
wide range of renewable energy water heaters used worldwide.
The procedure for using this International Standard is illustrated in the figure below. The general concept is to
develop computer models that describe the performance of every component of the solar water heating
system. These models can be based on specific tests (listed herein and in EN 12977-2 and AS/NZS 4234).
These models are then combined in a system simulation that can be used to estimate the performance of the
complete solar heating system under specified hot water usage and weather conditions. Information for users
of this International Standard is presented in Annexes I and J.
vi © ISO 2013 – All rights reserved

---------------------- Page: 6 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
Component Tests
- Solar collecting unit
o Active (forced circulation)
o Passive (thermosiphon, integral collector
storage)
- Storage vessels
o Solar
o Backup water heater
- Controller
- Pump(s)
Weather Solar Water Heating System Computer Hot Water Usage
Simulation Model
Estimate of:
- Energy output
- Backup fuel consumption
- Auxiliary energy consumption
- Savings compared to conventional water heating system


It is the intent of this part of ISO 9459 to be compatible with EN 12977-2, “Thermal solar systems and
components, Custom built systems, Test methods” such that tests conducted for use by certification bodies
can be done in accordance with either one interchangeably.
The terms “normative” and “informative” have been used in this International Standard to define the
application of the annex to which they apply. A “normative” annex is an integral part of an International
Standard, whereas an “informative” annex is only for information and guidance.
© ISO 2013 – All rights reserved vii

---------------------- Page: 7 ----------------------
INTERNATIONAL STANDARD ISO 9459-4:2013(E)

Solar heating — Domestic water heating systems —
Part 4:
System performance characterization by means of component
tests and computer simulation
1 Scope
This International Standard specifies a method of evaluating the annual energy performance of solar water
heaters using a combination of test results for component performance and a mathematical model to
determine an annual load cycle task performance under specified weather and load conditions. The procedure
is applicable to solar water heaters with integral backup or preheating into a conventional storage or
instantaneous water heater and to integral collector storage water heaters.
System operating requirements specified in this International Standard are for the purpose of determining an
annual performance rating for domestic water heaters. There are no product design or operation requirements
in this International Standard.
2 Normative references
The following referenced documents are indispensable for the application of this document. For dated
references, only the edition cited applies. For undated references, the latest edition of the referenced
document (including any amendments) applies.
ISO 9488:1999, Solar energy — Vocabulary
ISO 9806 (all parts), Test methods for solar collectors
EN 12977 (all parts):2012, Thermal solar systems and components — Custom built systems
EN 12975 (all parts):2006, Thermal solar systems and components — Solar collectors
EN 12976 (all parts):2006, Thermal solar systems and components — Factory made systems
AS 1056.1:1991, Storage water heaters — General requirements
AS/NZS 2712:2007, Solar and heat pump water heaters — Design and construction
AS/NZS 2535:2007, Test methods for solar collectors
3 Terms and definitions
For the purposes of this document, the terms and definitions given in ISO 9488 and the following apply.
There are two differences with ISO 9488-1999:
© ISO 2013 – All rights reserved 1

---------------------- Page: 8 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
 auxiliary energy is used here to represent energy consumed by pumps, fans, and controls in a solar
heating system
 backup energy refers to energy contributed by a source other than solar
3.1
tilt angle
angle between the absorbing surface of the collector and the horizontal
3.2
container
vessel including fittings, in which the heated water is stored; sometimes referred to as a store, storage
container, cylinder, storage vessel, or tank
3.3
electricity supply options

3.3.1
continuous
continuously available electricity supply
3.3.2
limited time of supply
electric supply available at limited times, as follows:
3.3.2.1
night rate
electricity supply at restricted night hours (see Annexes A and B for typical availability times)
3.3.2.2
extended off-peak
electricity supply during extended hours (see Annexes A and B for typical availability times)
3.4
dual element tanks
tanks incorporating dual electric elements at different levels in the tank
Note: Each element may be connected to a different electric supply or be operated under local control.
3.5
heat pump water heater, solar assisted
a system incorporating a compressor (vapour compression), an evaporator exposed to ambient air or solar
radiation, or both, a condenser and a water container heated either directly or indirectly by the condenser
3.6
one-shot backup
operation of a backup heat source for one heating cycle
Note: The heater is returned to normal control after one heating cycle.
3.7
factory-made solar water heater
package systems are batch products, sold as complete and ready to install kits with fixed configurations
Note: Systems of this category are considered as a single product and assessed as a whole.
2 © ISO 2013 – All rights reserved

---------------------- Page: 9 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
3.8
reference water heater
a conventional water heater used to define annual purchased energy use for the purpose of computing energy
savings of other products
3.9
tank nodes
horizontal sections of a storage tank
Note: Used in the simulation program to model thermal stratification in the storage tank.
3.10
tank modelling options

3.10.1
fixed inlet positions
fluid flows into the storage tank are considered to mix with the contents of the tank node at the same level with
the inlet fitting
3.10.2
variable inlet positions
fluid flows into the storage tank are considered to rise or fall to the level of the tank node with the closest
temperature to the inlet flow
3.11
computer simulation model
TRNSYS or equivalent computer program used to simulate the performance of solar water heating
components and systems
4 Symbols, units and nomenclature
Symbol Units Meaning
a, b, c [-] correlation coefficients for solar collector efficiency
B [MJ/year] annual energy used by a conventional water heater
c
B [MJ/year] annual electrical energy used by water heater
e
B [MJ/year] annual gas energy used by water heater
g
B [MJ/year] annual backup energy for a solar or heat pump water heater
s
C [kJ/(kg C)] heat capacity
p
C [-] modified capacity ratio
rmod
DE [MJ] difference in energy content of a tank between the start and the end of
a heat loss or warm-up test
d [m] diameter
e [W] electrical power use during burner operation
n
e [W] electrical power use during standby
sb
E [%] thermal efficiency of gas water heater
© ISO 2013 – All rights reserved 3

---------------------- Page: 10 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
E [MJ/year] integrated energy added to tank from gas combustion
g
f [-] purchased energy savings relative to a conventional water heater
R
(BcBs)/Bc
2]

G [Wm beam irradiance on the collector aperture
b
2] 4
G [Wm net long wave irradiance (λ>3µm) (Gs  σT )
L a
2]
G [Wm extraterrestrial solar irradiance
o
G [-] Grashoff number
r
2]
G [Wm long wave thermal irradiance (λ>3µm)
S
2]
G [Wm hemispherical solar irradiance on the collector aperture
T
2
h [W/m K] heat loss coefficient
K [-] solar collector angle modifier
τα
K , K [-] bi-axial incidence angle modifiers
NS EW
K [-] average clearness index for specified test
T
M [MJ/h] maintenance rate [standing or stand-by heat loss rate from a heated
water tank]
M [kg] mass withdrawn from the storage vessel
drawn
M [kg/s] mass flow rate
rate
M [kg/s] mass flow rate through a system
sys
M *C [kJ/K] capacitance
tank p
n [-] Julian day of the year (1-365)N [-] number of events
P [Pa] pressure drop
Pr [-] Prandtl number
Q [kJ] energy purged from the system after the wait or irradiance period
del
Q [Lj] initial charge energy of a tank or system when subjected to an
initial
instantaneous purge between two set temperatures.
R [MJ/h] determined gas consumption
Re [-] Reynolds number
t [h:min:s] duration of test
Time [s] decay test duration
decay
T [°C] temperature
T [°C] mean collector fluid temperature
4 © ISO 2013 – All rights reserved

---------------------- Page: 11 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
T [°C] ambient temperature
a
T [°C] annual average ambient outdoor air temperatureT [K] thermostat dead
a, avg db
band
T [°C] temperature of the water delivered from the DHW system at the outlet
del
of the system
T [°C] collector inlet fluid temperature
i
T [°C] mean temperature of water in the storage tank
W
T [°C] environment temperature (ie. temperature of air surrounding the
env
storage vessel)
T [°C] average environment temperature
env ave
T [°C] temperature of the water in a test system at the beginning of a
high
high-temperature test (typically 55  60 °C)
T [°C] temperature of the liquid entering the storage vessel
in
T [°C] temperature of the water in the test system at the beginning of a test
initial
(heat loss or warm-up)
T [°C] temperature of the water in a test system at the beginning of a
low
low-temperature test (preferably near ambient temperature)
T [°C] average tank fluid temperature
tank ave
T [°C] final average tank fluid temperature after the decay or irradiation, period
tank ave final
T [°C] initial average tank fluid temperature before the decay or irradiation
tank ave ini
period
T [°C] final average tank fluid temperature after the purge period. This value is
tank ave purge
usually estimated by averaging the tank inlet temperature and T
del.
∆t [s] change in time
T [°C] manufacturer's recommended thermostat setting
set
T [°C] sky temperature
sky
-1
u [ms ] surrounding air speed over the solar collector (or evaporator)
2
U [W/m K] heat loss coefficient
UA [W/K] heat loss coefficient  area product for the tank
UA total UA loss of the storage tank from a decay test with the system
isolated loss total
piping installed
UA installed total UA loss of the storage tank from a decay test
installed loss total
α [-] unglazed collector hemispherical absorber absorptance, short wave
© ISO 2013 – All rights reserved 5

---------------------- Page: 12 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
 [-] slope or tilt, the angle between the plane of the collector and the
horizontal
ε [-] unglazed collector hemispherical absorber emittance, long wave
 [-] modified effectiveness
mod
η [-] solar collector efficiency
 [-] latitude, the angular location north or south of the equator
θ [rad] incidence angle relative to the collector aperture normal
 [-] orientation angle, the direction which a collector faces, expressed as
the azimuth angle of the horizontal projection of the surface normal
 [W/mK] thermal conductivity
5 Application
The procedure in this International Standard uses a mathematical model to assess annual energy task
performance; hence the application of the procedure is restricted only by the availability of suitable
mathematical models. Weather data and typical modelling data files are specified in Annex G. The operating
conditions and product configurations to be used for evaluating the energy performance of a water heater are
specific to certification or incentive programs and are not defined in this International Standard.
This International Standard can be applied to solar water heaters with the following:
a) flat plate, concentrating or evacuated tubular solar collectors,
b) thermosiphon or forced fluid circulation through the solar collectors,
c) collector loop heat exchangers,
d) systems for combined domestic hot water preparation and space heating (combisystems),
e) integral collector storage,
f) horizontal or vertical water storage tanks,
g) storage with one or more electrical heating elements,
h) storage tanks with internal gas backup heaters,
i) solar preheat systems in series with instantaneous water heaters,
j) solar thermal systems combined with heat pumps (e.g., solar collectors acting as the refrigerant
evaporator).
Other water heater configurations incorporating the above components may also be modelled.
For limited time-of-supply electric storage water heaters, the temperature stratification in the storage tank is
evaluated throughout the day and used to quantify the variation of tank heat loss with time, due to cooling of
the bottom of the tank. Mixing during load draw off and conduction between the hot and cold layers in the tank
is also included. All storage tanks shall be rated for standing heat loss and maintenance rate. The operational
heat loss accounting for non-uniform insulation around the tank and thermal stratification in the tank is
determined by the annual load cycle performance model.
6 © ISO 2013 – All rights reserved

---------------------- Page: 13 ----------------------
ISO 9459-4:2013(E)
6 Test method
6.1 Introduction
This International Standard defines a means of evaluating the purchased energy use of water heaters
operating under specified weather and load conditions.
For solar water heaters, this standard can be used for any system type that can be reasonably modelled in a
computer simulation model. The performance of individual components is evaluated under ISO 9806, AS 4552,
AS/NZS 4692.1, AS 1056.1, EN 12975, EN 12976, and EN 12977. The performance of heat pump water
heaters with evaporators exposed directly to solar radiation is evaluated using test results for the evaporator
evaluated under ISO 9806 and performance of the compressor is evaluated under ASHRAE Standard 23-93.
The purchased energy use calculated is only representative of the product model described in Annex A.
6.2 Component testing
6.2.1 Storage vessels
There are a wide variety of storage vessels available. They range from simple single-wall tanks to double-wall
(mantle) vessels with multip
...