prEN 18462
(Main)Furniture - Circularity - Evaluation method for maintenance, repair and refurbishing capability
- Abstract
This document provides an evaluation method including a set of criteria for evaluating the ability of priority parts of products to be maintained, repaired and refurbished that lead to an extension of the lifetime of a product.
The evaluation criteria are intended to support the user in designing a product which can be easily maintained, repaired and refurbished irrespective of materials or construction methods used.
The evaluation method does not include usefulness and/or cost-effectiveness of the repair and refurbishment or assessing the overall degree of circularity of furniture products. For this additional complementary evaluation methods for other aspects are necessary.
- Status
- Not Published
- Publication Date
- 02-Dec-2027
- Technical Committee
- CEN/TC 207 - Furniture
- Drafting Committee
- CEN/TC 207/WG 10 - Requirements and tools for furniture circularity
- Current Stage
- 4010 - Start of draft translation - Enquiry
- Start Date
- 29-Sep-2026
- Completion Date
- 24-Sep-2026
prEN 18462 is a draft European Standard from the European Committee for Standardization (CEN) on furniture circularity. It specifies an evaluation method for deciding whether priority parts of furniture can be maintained, repaired and refurbished so the product life can be extended. The method is aimed at designers, engineers, manufacturers and quality managers who need a common way to judge and compare design choices.
What does prEN 18462 specify?
prEN 18462 specifies a criterion-based method for evaluating the maintainability, repairability and refurbishing capability of priority parts of furniture. It focuses on how easily those parts can be handled in practice, rather than on the economic value of repair or on an overall circularity score.
The document is organized into scope, terms and definitions, guidance on how to use the method, rules for determining priority parts, and criteria and classes for evaluation. Clause 2 states that there are no normative references.
The informative annexes expand the main method and show how to apply it.
| Annex | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Annex A | Structure and content of instructions related to this document |
| Annex B | Criteria for the ability to maintain, repair and refurbish |
| Annex C | Determination of the priority parts |
What are the key requirements of prEN 18462?
prEN 18462 sets out a stepwise method: identify priority parts, evaluate them against defined criteria, then use the results to improve the product design. In practice, that means the document is meant to support design decisions, not to certify a product or rank it by a single score.
1. Identify priority parts before evaluating anything
Clause 5 says the manufacturer should first determine which parts matter most for function, reliability, durability and lifespan. Parts linked to the product’s primary or secondary function, and parts that affect surface technical function, are the main focus.
This matters because not every part needs the same level of attention. The method is built around parts whose failure or wear would most strongly affect the furniture’s use.
2. Use the right evidence when selecting priority parts
Clause 5 points to multiple sources for identifying priority parts, including regulatory requirements, the manufacturer, suppliers, repair or maintenance organizations, scientific literature, study reports and customer feedback. For products already on the market, it also points to complaint data, physical testing, material and part testing and calculations such as FEM. For new designs, it adds testing and risk analysis such as FMEA.
In practice, the user is expected to base the prioritization on evidence, not guesswork. That helps make the evaluation defendable and repeatable.
3. Treat inspection, cleaning, maintenance, repair and refurbishment as related but different processes
Clause 5 separates the processes and explains how they relate. Inspection applies to the whole product, cleaning focuses on visible parts and soiling, maintenance keeps the product in a condition for its intended purpose, repair restores a defective product or part, and refurbishment combines inspection, maintenance and repair.
This matters because the same part can be relevant for one process and not another. It also means refurbishment is assessed as the combined case, so its priority parts include those found for inspection, maintenance and repair.
4. Evaluate each priority part with the clause 6 criteria
Clause 6 uses ordered classes for the main practical factors that affect maintainability and repairability. These include the number of persons needed, disassembly and assembly depth, ability to handle weight, ease of locating and accessing parts, and the comprehensibility of connections.
For a designer, this means the product should be arranged so that priority parts are reachable, understandable and removable without unnecessary effort. For a buyer or quality manager, it gives a way to compare different designs or suppliers on practical repair effort.
5. Check whether the necessary information is available to the right people
Clause 6 also evaluates the completeness of cleaning, maintenance and repair information, and whether that information is available to relevant stakeholders, independent service providers or manufacturer-authorized service providers. Annex A gives a recommended structure for instructions, including safety information, tools, preparatory measures, maintenance plans, diagnosis, spare parts, dis/re-assembly and repair procedures.
This matters because a part may be physically repairable but still difficult to service if the instructions are unclear or unavailable. The document therefore treats information access as part of circular design.
6. Consider skills, tools, spare parts, materials and interfaces
Clause 6 includes criteria for the skill level required, the complexity and diversity of tools, the availability and compatibility of spare parts and surface materials, the reusability or exchangeability of connectors and fasteners, the working environment, and diagnostic and support interfaces. Annex B shows which criteria apply to maintenance, repair and refurbishment, and which apply differently for repair cases such as replacing a defective part, repairing a removed part and reinstalling it, or repairing a part in place.
In practice, this means the product should be designed for the level of service access that will actually be needed. If a special workshop, special tools or manufacturer access is required, that affects the evaluation.
7. Use the results to improve the design
Clause 4 says the results can be documented in tables or matrices, compared across design options or suppliers, and used to improve the product by simplifying disassembly or extending spare-part availability. Annex C supports this with a process flow and examples.
This is the practical purpose of the document: not just to score a product, but to show where design changes can improve repair and refurbishment capability.
What terms does prEN 18462 define?
prEN 18462 defines the terms used to evaluate furniture circularity so readers can apply the method consistently.
- Product - a furniture object used in domestic, office, public, outdoor, educational or other institutional settings; in this document, product and furniture can be used synonymously.
- Part - a sub-unit of a product, including connectors and fasteners, and it may be an assembly, sub-assembly or component.
- Inspection - the process of examining a product so that parts needing maintenance or repair can be identified.
- Maintenance - actions taken to keep a product in a condition where it can fulfil its intended purpose.
- Repair - actions taken to return a defective product or part to a condition where it fulfils its intended purpose.
- Refurbishment - actions to prepare, clean, test, service and, where necessary, repair a product so that its performance or functionality is restored within the original intended use and performance range.
- Lifespan - the period during which the product functions for its intended purpose.
- Surface technical function - a secondary function of the outer layer of a product that serves protection, hygiene or functional improvement; the document treats surface overall appearance as a separate, tertiary matter.
Who uses prEN 18462?
prEN 18462 is intended for furniture designers, engineers, manufacturers and quality managers. It gives them a common method for designing products so that priority parts are easier to maintain, repair and refurbish.
It is also useful for organizations that evaluate repairability and refurbishing conditions, such as maintenance and repair providers, product suppliers and teams comparing design variants or suppliers. The document is especially relevant during the design and construction phase, when decisions about parts, interfaces, instructions and spare-part strategy have the biggest effect.
Which standards are used with prEN 18462?
prEN 18462 states that there are no normative references, but it cites several standards as sources for terms and related methods.
| Standard | What it contributes |
|---|---|
| EN 17902:2023 | Provides related circularity terminology and an aligned dis/re-assembly capability context; Annex A also points to its informative Annex I for dis/re-assembly instructions |
| EN 45560:2024 | Supplies the definition of component |
| EN 45552:2020 | Supplies the definition of primary function |
| EN 62542:2013 | Supplies the definitions of secondary function and tertiary function |
| EN 15338 | Appears in Annex C as an example for drawer runner reliability levels |
What does the prEN 18462 document contain?
prEN 18462 contains class tables for the practical factors that affect maintenance, repair and refurbishing capability, including people needed, steps required, weight, access, information, skills, tools, spare parts, compatibility, working environment and diagnostic interfaces. These tables are used for design evaluation and comparison, not for reproducing a repair procedure.
Annex A sets out the content that maintenance, repair and refurbishment instructions should cover, from safety information and tools to diagnosis, spare parts and substantial modifications. Annex B maps which criteria apply to maintenance, repair and refurbishment, and distinguishes among three repair cases.
Annex C provides a flowchart for determining priority parts and a worked drawer example showing how intended use, reliability and design quality affect the priority-part decision. It is intended to help users apply Clause 5 in practice when evaluating real furniture designs.
Frequently Asked Questions
prEN 18462 is a draft published by the European Committee for Standardization (CEN). Its full title is "Furniture - Circularity - Evaluation method for maintenance, repair and refurbishing capability". This standard covers: This document provides an evaluation method including a set of criteria for evaluating the ability of priority parts of products to be maintained, repaired and refurbished that lead to an extension of the lifetime of a product. The evaluation criteria are intended to support the user in designing a product which can be easily maintained, repaired and refurbished irrespective of materials or construction methods used. The evaluation method does not include usefulness and/or cost-effectiveness of the repair and refurbishment or assessing the overall degree of circularity of furniture products. For this additional complementary evaluation methods for other aspects are necessary.
This document provides an evaluation method including a set of criteria for evaluating the ability of priority parts of products to be maintained, repaired and refurbished that lead to an extension of the lifetime of a product. The evaluation criteria are intended to support the user in designing a product which can be easily maintained, repaired and refurbished irrespective of materials or construction methods used. The evaluation method does not include usefulness and/or cost-effectiveness of the repair and refurbishment or assessing the overall degree of circularity of furniture products. For this additional complementary evaluation methods for other aspects are necessary.
prEN 18462 is classified under the following ICS (International Classification for Standards) categories: 97.140 - Furniture. The ICS classification helps identify the subject area and facilitates finding related standards.
prEN 18462 is associated with the following European legislation: EU Directives/Regulations: 2009/125/EC. When a standard is cited in the Official Journal of the European Union, products manufactured in conformity with it benefit from a presumption of conformity with the essential requirements of the corresponding EU directive or regulation.
prEN 18462 is available in PDF format for immediate download after purchase. The document can be added to your cart and obtained through the secure checkout process. Digital delivery ensures instant access to the complete standard document.
Standards Content (Sample)
SLOVENSKI STANDARD
01-december-2026
Pohištvo - Krožnost - Metoda vrednotenja zmožnosti za vzdrževanje, popravilo in
obnovo
Furniture - Circularity - Evaluation method for maintenance, repair and refurbishing
capability
Möbel - Kreislauffähigkeit - Bewertungsmethode für Wartungs-, Reparatur- und
Aufarbeitungsfähigkeit
Mobilier - Circularité - Méthode d'évaluation de la capacité d'entretien, de reparartion et
de remise à neuf
Ta slovenski standard je istoveten z: prEN 18462
ICS:
97.140 Pohištvo Furniture
2003-01.Slovenski inštitut za standardizacijo. Razmnoževanje celote ali delov tega standarda ni dovoljeno.
DRAFT
EUROPEAN STANDARD
NORME EUROPÉENNE
EUROPÄISCHE NORM
December 2026
ICS
English Version
Furniture - Circularity - Evaluation method for
maintenance, repair and refurbishing capability
Mobilier - Circularité - Méthode d'évaluation de la Möbel - Kreislauffähigkeit - Bewertungsmethode für
capacité d'entretien, de reparartion et de remise à neuf Wartungs-, Reparatur- und Aufarbeitungsfähigkeit
This draft European Standard is submitted to CEN members for enquiry. It has been drawn up by the Technical Committee
CEN/TC 207.
If this draft becomes a European Standard, CEN members are bound to comply with the CEN/CENELEC Internal Regulations
which stipulate the conditions for giving this European Standard the status of a national standard without any alteration.
This draft European Standard was established by CEN in three official versions (English, French, German). A version in any other
language made by translation under the responsibility of a CEN member into its own language and notified to the CEN-CENELEC
Management Centre has the same status as the official versions.
CEN members are the national standards bodies of Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark,
Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands,
Norway, Poland, Portugal, Republic of North Macedonia, Romania, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Türkiye
and United Kingdom.
Recipients of this draft are invited to submit, with their comments, notification of any relevant patent rights of which they are
aware and to provide supporting documentation.
Warning : This document is not a European Standard. It is distributed for review and comments. It is subject to change without
notice and shall not be referred to as a European Standard.
EUROPEAN COMMITTEE FOR STANDARDIZATION
C O M I T É E U R O P É E N D E N O R M A L I S A T I O N
E U R O P Ä I S C H E S K O M I T E E F Ü R N O R M U N G
CEN-CENELEC Management Centre: Rue de la Science 23, B-1040 Brussels
© 2026 CEN All rights of exploitation in any form and by any means reserved Ref. No. prEN 18462 E
worldwide for CEN national Members.
Contents Page
European foreword . 4
Introduction . 5
1 Scope . 6
2 Normative references . 6
3 Terms and definitions . 6
4 How to use the document . 9
4.1 Purpose of the method . 9
4.2 Step 1 – Identification of Priority Parts . 9
4.3 Step 2 – Considerations regarding the application of process-specific
characteristics in the context of determining priority parts . 10
4.3.1 General . 10
4.3.2 Cumulative determination of priority parts . 10
4.4 Step 3 – Evaluation of Priority Parts . 10
4.5 Step 4 – Use of the evaluation results . 10
5 Determination of the priority parts to be evaluated . 10
5.1 General . 10
5.2 Determination of priority parts for inspection . 11
5.3 Determination of priority parts for cleaning . 11
5.4 Determination of priority parts for maintenance . 12
5.5 Determination of priority parts for repair . 12
5.6 Determination of priority parts for refurbishment . 12
6 Criteria and classes . 12
6.1 General . 12
6.2 Number of Persons . 12
6.3 Disassembly depth and assembly depth . 12
6.4 Ability to handle - weight . 13
6.5 Ease of locating, Accessibility, Comprehensibility . 13
6.6 Types and availability of maintenance, repair and replacement information . 13
6.6.1 General . 13
6.6.2 Completeness of information . 13
6.6.3 Availability of information for specific stakeholders . 14
6.7 Skill level for maintenance and/or repair . 14
6.8 Tools for maintenance and/or repair . 14
6.8.1 General . 14
6.8.2 Tools complexity for maintenance and/or repair . 14
6.8.3 Tools diversity for maintenance and/or repair . 15
6.9 Availability of spare parts or materials for the maintenance, repair, and
refurbishment of surfaces . 15
6.9.1 General . 15
6.9.2 Availability of spare parts or surface materials in relation to the provision for
specific stakeholders . 15
6.9.3 Availability of spare parts or surface materials in relation to the duration of
availability . 16
6.10 Characteristics and variety of spare parts and material for surface maintenance,
repair and refurbishment . 16
6.10.1 General . 16
6.10.2 Compatibility of spare parts . 16
6.10.3 Connectors and fastener types . 17
6.10.4 Connections, connectors and fasteners re-usability and exchange-ability . 17
6.10.5 Compatibility of materials for surface maintenance, repair and refurbishment . 18
6.11 Working environment for maintenance, repair and refurbishment . 18
6.12 Diagnostic and support interfaces . 18
6.12.1 General . 18
6.12.2 Availability of a diagnostic-and support interface . 18
Annex A (informative) Structure and content of instructions related to this document . 20
A.1 General . 20
A.2 Dis/re-assembly instructions in connection with this document . 20
A.3 Maintenance and repair instructions for furniture, including parts and surfaces . 20
A.3.1 Purpose . 20
A.3.2 Structure and content . 20
A.4 Refurbishment instruction . 25
A.4.1 General . 25
A.4.2 Inspection . 25
A.4.3 Procedures for refurbishment . 25
Annex B (informative) Criteria for the ability to maintain, repair and refurbish . 26
B.1 Overview of criteria . 26
Annex C (informative) Determination of the priority parts . 28
C.1 Purpose . 28
C.2 Process flow and influencing factors . 28
C.3 Example of use . 30
Bibliography . 32
European foreword
This document (prEN 18462) has been prepared by Technical Committee CEN/TC 207 Furniture.
This document is currently submitted to the CEN Enquiry.
This document has been prepared under a mandate given to CEN by the European Commission and the
European Free Trade Association, and supports essential requirements of EU Directive(s).
Introduction
Core elements for sustainable products and their circularity are in the longevity of products and the
supporting measures and strategies to extend the lifespan of products.
These measures include the maintenance, repair and refurbishment of products and/or their parts
and/or their surfaces. They thus reflect the terms addressed in current European legislation Proposal
for Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation[1].
The decision as to whether a furniture or parts including their surfaces, should be repaired or
refurbished depends on a number of factors. These may be economic, legal and/or sustainability aspects.
When considering the parts, the concept of prioritising parts is applied, which is mentioned by the Joint
Research Centre of the EU Commission in its study on ESPR and has already been applied in EN
17902:2023 [2].
In addition, occupational health and safety can be taken into account during maintenance, repair and
refurbishment.
This document provides an evaluation method and thus expertise for the design and construction phase
of the products and their priority parts.
This document is intended to support designers and engineers in designing furniture in such a way that
the costs of maintenance, repair and refurbishment after placement on the market can be kept as low
as possible.
The costs themselves and the assessment of the economic efficiency of a repair or refurbishment are
not considered, since this decision is made by other stakeholders, taking into account other factors such
as sustainability aspects and emotional attachment to the furniture.
For this purpose, there are defined criteria with corresponding classes for evaluating their
implementation and corresponding possibilities for further improvement.
1 Scope
This document provides an evaluation method including a set of criteria for evaluating the ability of
priority parts of products to be maintained, repaired and refurbished that lead to an extension of the
lifetime of a product.
The evaluation criteria are intended to support the user of this document in designing a product which
can be easily maintained, repaired and refurbished irrespective of materials or construction methods
used.
The evaluation method does not consider usefulness and/or cost-effectiveness of the repair and
refurbishment.
This document does not include requirements.
For assessing the overall degree of circularity of furniture products, additional complementary
evaluation methods need to be considered.
2 Normative references
There are no normative references in this document.
3 Terms and definitions
For the purposes of this document, the following terms and definitions apply.
• ISO Online browsing platform: available at http://www.iso.org/obp
• IEC Electropedia: available at http://www.electropedia.org/
3.1
product
physical-based object designed or utilized as furniture in domestic, office, public, outdoor areas,
educational and other institutions
Note 1 to entry: The terms product and furniture can be used synonymously.
[SOURCE: EN 17902:2023 [2], 3.1]
3.2
component
constituent of a product (3.1) which cannot be fragmented without losing its particular function (3.10)
[SOURCE: EN 45560:2024 [3], 3.3.1]
3.3
part
sub-unit of a product (3.1), including connectors and fasteners as component (3.2)
Note 1 to entry: A part can be understood as an assembly, sub-assembly or a component.
[SOURCE: EN 17902:2023 [2], 3.2 amended]
3.4
inspection
process in which the product (3.1) is examined for limitations of primary or secondary functions so that
parts requiring maintenance (3.6) or repair (3.7) can be identified
3.5
cleaning
one or more measures carried out to clean the visible parts from soiling and to contribute to the
reduction or prevention of signs of wear or impairment of appearance
Note 1 to entry: In addition to the regular cleaning of certain parts, cleaning can also serve as a preparatory step
for maintenance (e.g. lubrication).
3.6
maintenance
one or more actions carried out to keep a product (3.1) in a condition where it is able to fulfil its intended
purpose
Note 1 to entry: Cleaning in itself does not constitute maintenance.
[SOURCE: [1] REGULATION (EU) 2024/1781, Article 2 (19)]
3.7
repair
one or more actions carried out to return a defective product (3.1) or waste to a condition where it
fulfils its intended purpose
Note 1 to entry: Repairs are carried out on the product or the part when installed, removing or replacing the part
concerned.
Note 2 to entry: The term waste is not considered here because the ESPR definition of refurbishment does not use
the term waste and repairing waste does not make sense in the context of this document.
[SOURCE: [1] REGULATION (EU) 2024/1781, Article 2 (20)]
3.8
refurbishment
actions carried out to prepare, clean, test, service and, where necessary, repair (3.7) a product (3.1) or
a discarded product (3.1) in order to restore its performance or functionality within the intended use
and range of performance originally conceived at the design stage at the time of the placing of the product
(3.1) on the market
[SOURCE: [1] REGULATION (EU) 2024/1781, Article 2 (18)]
3.9
lifespan
time period under which the product (3.1) functions for its intended purpose
Note 1 to entry: Lifespan can be based on regulatory requirements or the average or usual reliability (3.14) of
products.
3.10
function
intended purpose a product (3.1) is designed for
3.11
primary function
function (3.10) fulfilling the intended use
Note 1 to entry: More than one primary function is possible.
[SOURCE: EN 45552:2020 [4], 3.1.2.1]
3.12
secondary function
function (3.10) that supplements or enhances a primary function (3.11)
[SOURCE: EN 62542:2013 [5], 5.14 amended]
3.13
tertiary function
function (3.10) other than a primary function (3.11) or a secondary function (3.12)
[SOURCE: EN 62542:2013 [5], 5.16, modified examples deleted]
3.14
reliability
probability that a product (3.1) functions as required under given conditions for a given duration without
an occurrence which results in a primary function (3.11) orsecondary function (3.12) of the product (3.1)
no longer being performed
[SOURCE: [1] REGULATION (EU) 2024/1781, Article 2 (23)]
3.15
durability
ability of a product (3.1) to maintain over time its function (3.10) and performance under specified
conditions of use, maintenance (3.6) and repair (3.7)
Note 1 to entry: Functional durability includes the possibility of extending the use phase by one or more repairs.
[SOURCE: [1] REGULATION (EU) 2024/1781, Article 2 (22)]
3.16
surface
outer boundary of a piece of furniture or parts thereof
Note 1 to entry: A surface interacts with its surroundings and the user.
Note 2 to entry: A surface includes hard substrates (e.g. solid wood, wood-based materials, stone, plastic) and
coverings of soft substrates (e.g. foams).
3.17
surface technical function
is a secondary function (3.12) and refers to the specific design of an outer layer to fulfil practical purposes
in terms of protection, hygiene and functional improvement in the position of use
3.18
Surface overall appearance
is a tertiary function (3.13) and results from the overall interaction of visual and tactile properties in
the area visible and tangible to the user in the position of use
Note 1 to entry: Visual and tactile properties are, e.g. colour, gloss, texture, roughness, reflection and structure.
3.19
surface reliability
probability that a surface (3.16) will maintain its technical function (3.10) under given conditions for a
given duration without an occurrence that causes the surface technical function (3.17) no longer be
performed
Note 1 to entry: Surface resistance as the basis for the reliability of furniture surfaces can be determined using
various standards.
3.20
surface durability
ability of a surface (3.16) to maintain its technical function (3.10) over time under specified
conditions of use, maintenance (3.6) and repair (3.7)
3.21
disassembly step
each stage of the process that ends with the removal of a part (3.3)
[SOURCE: EN 17902:2023 [2], 3.6]
3.22
assembly step
each stage of the process that ends with the assembly of a part (3.3)
[SOURCE: EN 17902:2023 [2], 3.7]
4 How to use the document
4.1 Purpose of the method
The purpose of the methodology described in this document is to develop and design products in such
a way that their durability (3.15) is optimized based on the reliability (3.14) of the parts and the ease of
maintenance, repair and refurbishing.
By systematically applying this method, manufacturers, their designers and quality managers can
ensure that their products have a long lifespan and meet customer expectations.
The methodology described in this document is to:
— Identify priority parts of a furniture product in Clause 5.
— Evaluate how easily these parts can be maintained, repaired, or refurbished.
— Use standardized criteria and classes to ensure comparability and transparency.
The procedure described in this document is divided into the following steps:
4.2 Step 1 – Identification of Priority Parts
The concept of ‘priority parts’ is based on the recognition that not all parts of a piece of furniture are
equally relevant to its functionality and reliability.
A priority part has a strong influence on:
— the functionality (primary function / secondary function) of the product,
— the reliability and durability and thus the lifespan of the product,
— and the technical function of the surface which has an influence on surface reliability (3.19) and
surface durability (3.20) .
NOTE 1 The overall appearance of the surface has a subjective design quality function in which subjectively
perceptible, personal effects or impressions of the product under consideration and not objectively quantifiable
and measurable effects on the functionality of the product play a corresponding role. Therefore, as a tertiary
function, the overall appearance cannot be used for assessment in connection with the priority parts and the effect
on functionality and reliability.
NOTE 2 Parts that are not visible or are of minor importance in normal use, as well as irregularities that are
only visible in raking light, are excluded from the assessment.
There are several sources of information for identifying priority parts as detailed under 5.1.
Examples for priority parts see Annex C.
4.3 Step 2 – Considerations regarding the application of process-specific
characteristics in the context of determining priority parts
4.3.1 General
The document considers different processes (inspection (3.4), cleaning (3.5), maintenance (3.6), repair
(3.7), refurbishment (3.8)) and their influencing factors and effects in relation to the durability of the
product.
4.3.2 Cumulative determination of priority parts
In this approach, the parts to be prioritized are determined directly for the refurbishment process, as
this represents the sum of all other processes, as explained in 5.6.
4.4 Step 3 – Evaluation of Priority Parts
Each priority part is evaluated using defined criteria and classes under Clause 6.
For detailed information, see Clause 6.
NOTE Table C.1 in Annex C provides an overview of the relevance and applicability of the individual criteria to
the respective processes.
4.5 Step 4 – Use of the evaluation results
— Document the evaluation of the prioritised parts in tables or matrices (per criterion, per class).
— Compare different designs (aesthetic and technical solutions), or suppliers.
— Use the results of the evaluation to improve the design in terms of circularity by making changes
to previously identified priority parts (e.g. by simplifying disassembly, extending the availability
of spare parts) so that they either lead to a different result in the classification or increase the
reliability of the part in a way that it is no longer considered as a priority part.
For detailed information, see informative Annex C.
5 Determination of the priority parts to be evaluated
5.1 General
In order to assess the ability to maintain, repair or refurbish a product, a list of priority parts needs to
be drawn up.
Not all parts are equally relevant for maintenance, repair or refurbishment and therefore priority parts
need to be determined by the manufacturer considering the intended use, based on experience or data
from products on the market or through testing etc.
In order to carry out this prioritisation, all parts should first be considered in the design process (new
design or design revision) in terms of their reliability. To this end, relevant data should be collected and
evaluated.
The following list of information sources, which is not exhaustive and, where available, can provide
valuable guidance, should be consulted.
— Regulatory requirements;
— Product manufacturer;
— Parts manufacturer or supplier;
— Repair or maintenance organisations;
— Scientific literature and study reports;
— Customer feedback.
In the case of products already existing on the market or products newly introduced onto the market
and created on the basis of existing technologies or designs (empirical values are available here), the
following lists of data, not exhaustive and if available, should be used:
— Complaint evaluation (field data, statistical evaluation);
— if necessary supplement with:
• Furniture testing (physical testing);
• Part and material testing, [physical testing, statistical evaluation];
• Calculations via e.g. Finite Element Method (FEM).
For products newly introduced onto the market and based on new technologies or new designs (no
empirical values are available here):
— Furniture testing (physical testing);
— Part and material testing, (physical testing, statistical evaluation], data are usually provided by the
supplier);
— Risk analysis such as Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA)/ Design-FMEA.
To assess the priority of parts, a distinction is made between inspection (3.4) , cleaning (3.5) and
maintenance (3.6) and repair (3.7) .
The influencing factors to be taken into account when determining priority parts, and the process
involved, are described in more detail in Annex C.
In the definition of refurbishment (3.8) , the measures inspection (3.4) , maintenance (3.6) and repair
(3.7) are included, so that the determination of the priority parts for these measures also determines
the priority parts for refurbishment (3.8) .
The concept of defining priority parts is also used in EN 17902:2023 [2].
5.2 Determination of priority parts for inspection
As the inspection (3.4) concerns the entire product (3.1) , it is not necessary to define priority parts.
5.3 Determination of priority parts for cleaning
A priority part for cleaning (3.5) is a part (3.3) that is relevant to the function (3.10) or Surface overall
appearance (3.18) of the product (3.1) and whose possible soiling when used as intended can lead to it
no longer functioning reliably and visible parts becoming visually unsightly.
Priority parts that can no longer be cleaned are considered defective and should be repaired or replaced.
5.4 Determination of priority parts for maintenance
A priority part for maintenance (3.6) is a part (3.3) that is relevant to the function (3.10) or Surface
overall appearance (3.18) of the product (3.1) . Due to a lack of maintenance (3.6) , can cause to no longer
function reliably when used as intended.
5.5 Determination of priority parts for repair
A priority part for repair is a part that is relevant to the primary function (3.11) or secondary function
(3.12) or surface technical function (3.17) of the product (3.1) and whose time in which it functions
reliably is shorter than the average lifespan (3.9) of the product (3.1) .
Reasonably foreseeable misuse should also be considered as sources of part failure that requires repair.
When assessing the repairability of priority parts, various scenarios may arise and should be considered
on a case-by-case basis. These possible scenarios are described in Table B.2 of Annex B.
5.6 Determination of priority parts for refurbishment
refurbishment (3.8) combines inspection (3.4) , maintenance (3.6) and repair (3.7) . In this respect, the
priority parts of the product (3.1) under consideration for refurbishment (3.8) are to be considered as
the sum of the priority parts under 5.2 to 5.5.
6 Criteria and classes
6.1 General
The criteria and classes per criterion to be considered and assessed for the evaluation of the ability to
maintain, repair and refurbish priority parts are listed below.
NOTE Some of the following criteria in this document, are in alignment with EN 17902:2023 [2], and looking
at the same aspect with a different focus.
6.2 Number of Persons
The number of persons needed for the maintenance, repair or refurbishment process can be assessed
using classes of criteria in Table 1.
Table 1 — Classes for number of persons
Class Description
A 1 person
B 2 persons
C > 2 persons
6.3 Disassembly depth and assembly depth
Classes of criteria in Table 2 include the disassembly steps (3.21) and assembly steps (3.22) and are
defined as an operation that ends with the removal or assembly of a part.
If fasteners or connectors are not visible, the disassembly sequence may require further steps to locate
the fasteners or connectors, e.g. by removing caps, trims.
Table 2 — Classes for dis/re-assembly depth
Class Description
A ≤ 5 steps
B > 5 to ≤ 15 steps
Class Description
C > 15 steps
6.4 Ability to handle - weight
The manageability of parts in regard to their weight can be assessed using a description of classes
provided in Table 3 include the weight in relation to the manageability of parts and are defined by the
single heaviest part (mass in kg) that is handled during the process. The determination of the heaviest
part includes the priority part.
Table 3 — Classes for weight
Class Description
A ≤ 5 kg
B > 5 kg to ≤ 10 kg
C > 10 kg to ≤ 15 kg
D > 15 kg
6.5 Ease of locating, Accessibility, Comprehensibility
Classes of criteria in Table 4 include the ease of locating of priority parts and its connections points,
connectors and fasteners. Accessibility describes the ability to allow the operator physical access to the
priority parts and the connection points, connectors and fasteners, if applicable, with the necessary
tools. Comprehensibility of connections describes the ability to understand how the connection works.
Table 4 — Classes for ease of locating, access and comprehension
Class Description
A located, accessed and understood directly, without additional information
B located, accessed and understood only via additional information (e.g. stickers, dis/re-assembly
instructions) or for other parts to first be disassembled
C not locatable, not accessed or not understood
6.6 Types and availability of maintenance, repair and replacement information
6.6.1 General
Types and availability of maintenance and repair information refers to both the completeness of the
information and its availability for different target stakeholder groups. These two perspectives are
evaluated one after the other.
6.6.2 Completeness of information
The availability of cleaning, maintenance and repair information is assessed in relation to its
completeness in accordance with Table 5.
Table 5 — Classification of the completeness of the information of cleaning, maintenance and
repair
Class Description
A Comprehensive and all relevant information available
B Partial, non-detailed information on all terms, or information only available on
individual terms
C No information available
6.6.3 Availability of information for specific stakeholders
For the cleaning, maintenance and repair processes, availability is assessed in relation to the provision
for specific groups of people in accordance with Table 6.
Information is considered available to groups of stakeholders if the following information from the
manufacturer is available:
— for classes A, B, C and D, a unique identification of the product and the information available for
this product, based on the trade name and type designation of the product;
— for target stakeholder group class A, the basic or comprehensive information to facilitate repair,
reuse or upgrade of the priority part;
— for target stakeholder group classes B and C, including the process by which each target group can
obtain the relevant information.
Table 6 — Classification of the availability of information in relation to its provision to specific
stakeholders
Class Description
A Available to relevant stakeholders
B Available to independent service providers
C Available to service providers authorised by manufacturers
D Not available
6.7 Skill level for maintenance and/or repair
Maintenance and/or repair requires certain technical abilities from the person carrying out the
maintenance and/or repair. This includes the ability to identify and locate the fault, access the faulty
part within the product, handle the tools safely and control any risk to the product, the environment
and the operator. Consequently, certain repair operations are only feasible for certain skill level
categories.
The skill levels can be categorised as shown in Table 7 below.
Table 7 — Classification for skill level for repair
Class Description
A Layperson, without specific experience or related qualifications
B Trained/educated person in furniture handling without specific authorization by
manufacturer
C Specialist, from manufacturer or authorized by manufacturer with specific training and
experience
6.8 Tools for maintenance and/or repair
6.8.1 General
Tools necessary for the maintenance and/or repair are determined by the product design and are an
objective characteristic of the product. Maintenance and repair processes can therefore be classified
according to the type and number of different tools that are necessary for their execution.
6.8.2 Tools complexity for maintenance and/or repair
Table 8 provides an overview of the complexity of the tools necessary for the maintenance and/or repair.
Table 8 — Classes for tools complexity
Class Description
A no tools are required
B standard household or commercially (DIY shops or online platforms) available tools can
be used
C cannot be carried out with standard household tools and the tools needed are not available
commercially (DIY shops or online platforms)
D no available tools
NOTE 1 Processes corresponding to class A or B cause fewer restrictions in terms of the variety of maintenance
or repair scenarios that can be carried out than processes corresponding to class C and D.
NOTE 2 Not all classes are applicable to every product type. For products used in certain applications,
especially in public areas (e.g. schools, barracks, prisons, e.t.c.), it is not always possible to achieve the best class
for safety reasons or to prevent unintentional disassembly (e.g. wilful damage) or repair.
6.8.3 Tools diversity for maintenance and/or repair
The criteria classes in Table 9 cover the diversity of tools and are defined by the number of different
tools that are required to repair a part. Different tools are tools that differ in the following characteristics,
e.g. geometry, size, drive form.
Table 9 — Number of tools necessary for the repair
Class Description
A ≤ 2
B > 2 to ≤ 5
C > 5
6.9 Availability of spare parts or materials for the maintenance, repair, and
refurbishment of surfaces
6.9.1 General
I many cases, the availability of spare parts or materials for the maintenance, repair, and refurbishment
of surfaces (in short: surface materials) is a prerequisite for successful repairs. The availability of spare
parts and surface materials refers to both the availability for different groups of stakeholders and the
availability over a specified period of time. These two aspects are assessed separately. The availability
of software and firmware can be assessed in the same way as for hardware parts and surface materials.
When defining product-specific assessment procedures, the user of this document may consider the
aspect of the delivery time of spare parts and surface materials. The usual delivery time in the market
environment or legal requirements can be used as a benchmark.
6.9.2 Availability of spare parts or surface materials in relation to the provision for specific
stakeholders
The availability of spare parts and surface materials in relation to provision for certain groups of
stakeholders is differentiated according to Table 10.
Spare parts and surface materials are considered available to the relevant group of stakeholders if the
following information from the manufacturer is publicly available:
— for classes A, B, C, a unique identification of the product and the parts of the product or product
group for which spare parts and surface materials are available, based on the trade name and type
designation;
— for class D, a unique identification of the product or product group for which spare parts and surface
materials are available, based on the trade name and type designation;
— for classes A, B and C, the procedure by which target groups A, B and/or C can each obtain the
necessary part;
— the process by which a spare parts or surface materials order can be fulfilled and target groups A,
B and/or C can each receive the necessary part;
If the above information is not publicly available from the manufacturer, the availability of spare parts
and surface materials is considered to be Class D.
Table 10 — Classification of the availability of spare parts or surface materials in relation to the
provision for specific stakeholders
Class Description
A publicly available
B Available for independent repair service providers
C Available for the manufacturer or for repair service providers authorized by
manufacturers
D No spare parts or surface materials available
6.9.3 Availability of spare parts or surface materials in relation to the duration of availability
Another aspect of repairability and the ability for refurbishment is the availability of spare parts or
surface materials in relation to the period of availability (unit: years) after placing on the market the
last unit of the corresponding product. The different classes of this availability are listed in Table 11.
Table 11 — Classification of the availability of spare parts or surface materials in relation to the
duration of availability
Class Description
A Availability of spare parts or surface materials according to manufacturer's specifications,
but at least three years longer than B
B Availability of spare parts or surface materials corresponds to the industry standard
lifespan of the product or availability corresponds to legal requirements
C No information on the duration of availability
NOTE Class C is not applicable if a corresponding legal regulation exists.
6.10 Characteristics and variety of spare parts and material for surface maintenance,
repair and refurbishment
6.10.1 General
The characteristics and variety of spare parts, in addition to the criteria described in 6.6, are fundamental
prerequisites for the ability to repair and refurbishment.
6.10.2 Compatibility of spare parts
The compatibility of spare parts can also influence the repairability and the possibility of refurbishing
a product. In addition to the functional compatibility of the spare parts (e.g. dimensions, range of
functions, offset), compatibility in terms of the connection with other parts and the appearance also
play a role. Table 12 provides a classification:
Table 12 — Classification of the compatibility of spare parts
Class Description
A Part with standardised functional compatibility and standardised compatibility in terms
of connection and appearance
B Part with cross-manufacturer- functional compatibility and cross manufacturer-
compatibility in terms of connection and appearance
C Part with manufacturer-specific functional compatibility and manufacturer-independent
compatibility in terms of connection and appearance
A: The functionality of the spare parts (e.g. dimensions, range of functions, offset) represents a market standard
and in terms of connection means that all connections represent a market standard. The same applies to the
appearance (e.g. surface structure, colour, e.t.c.) of the spare parts.
B: A part that has at least one interface that is operated by at least two different manufacturers.
C: A part that has a manufacturer-specific functionality or that can only be operated by one manufacturer in terms
of how it is connected to other parts or how it appears (e.g. surface structure, colour, e.t.c.). In this case, the
manufacturer should be aware that the role they play in terms of the availability of spare parts is more important
than if it is a standard part.
6.10.3 Connectors and fastener types
The number of different connectors and fastener types required to be removed/ replaced in order to
dis/ re-assemble a priority part can be evaluated by a corresponding classes provided in Table 13.
Connectors and fasteners are considered to be different if they vary in characteristics like geometry,
material or form. Multi-part connectors are considered as one connector type for this criterion.
Table 13 — Classes for connectors and fasteners
Class Description
A ≤ 2 connectors/fasteners
B > 2 to ≤ 5 connectors/fasteners
C > 5 connectors/fasteners
6.10.4 Connections, connectors and fasteners re-usability and exchange-ability
The reusability or exchange-ability of connections, connectors and fasteners can be evaluated by the
corresponding classes required to evaluate this criterion provided Table 14.
Classes of criteria in Table 14 include the reusability or exchangeability of connections, connectors and
fasteners and are determined by the possibility to reuse or exchange after dis/re-assembly of priority
parts while maintaining the functionality and durability of the connection and corresponding parts. For
the assessment of reusability, the dis/re-assembly instructions shall clearly indicate which connector
and parts of a connection type are to be disassembled and subsequently re
...



