Road marking materials - Road trials

This European Standard gives guidance for conducting road trials for road marking materials intended for use in both permanent and temporary road marking. Recommendations are given for test sites, for the application of road marking materials on the test sites, for the parameters to be measured and the frequency of the measurements and for the presentation of the results in the form of a test report.

Straßenmarkierungsmaterialien - Feldprüfungen

Diese Europäische Norm legt die Anforderungen für die Durchführung von Feldprüfungen mit Straßenmarkie¬rungs¬materialien fest, die sowohl für den dauerhaften als auch für vorübergehenden Einsatz vorgesehen sind. Sie enthält Einzelheiten zu Prüffeldern, zur Applikation des Straßenmarkierungsmaterials auf den Prüffeldern, zu den zu messenden Parametern, zur Häufigkeit der Messungen und zur Darstellung der Ergebnisse in Form eines Prüfberichtes.

Produits de marquage routier - Essais routiers

Materiali za označevanje vozišča - Terenski preskusi

General Information

Status
Not Published
Public Enquiry End Date
31-Jan-2009
Technical Committee
Current Stage
98 - Abandoned project (Adopted Project)
Start Date
02-Aug-2012
Due Date
07-Aug-2012
Completion Date
02-Aug-2012

Relations

Buy Standard

Draft
prEN 1824:2009
English language
30 pages
sale 10% off
Preview
sale 10% off
Preview
e-Library read for
1 day

Standards Content (Sample)

SLOVENSKI STANDARD
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
01-februar-2009
0DWHULDOL]DR]QDþHYDQMHYR]LãþD7HUHQVNLSUHVNXVL
Road marking materials - Road trials
Straßenmarkierungsmaterialien - Feldprüfungen
Produits de marquage routier - Essais routiers
Ta slovenski standard je istoveten z: prEN 1824
ICS:
93.080.20 Materiali za gradnjo cest Road construction materials
oSIST prEN 1824:2009 en,fr,de
2003-01.Slovenski inštitut za standardizacijo. Razmnoževanje celote ali delov tega standarda ni dovoljeno.

---------------------- Page: 1 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009

---------------------- Page: 2 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
EUROPEAN STANDARD
DRAFT
prEN 1824
NORME EUROPÉENNE
EUROPÄISCHE NORM
September 2008
ICS 93.080.20 Will supersede EN 1824:1998
English Version
Road marking materials - Road trials
Produits de marquage routier - Essais routiers Straßenmarkierungsmaterialien - Feldprüfungen
This draft European Standard is submitted to CEN members for enquiry. It has been drawn up by the Technical Committee CEN/TC 226.
If this draft becomes a European Standard, CEN members are bound to comply with the CEN/CENELEC Internal Regulations which
stipulate the conditions for giving this European Standard the status of a national standard without any alteration.
This draft European Standard was established by CEN in three official versions (English, French, German). A version in any other language
made by translation under the responsibility of a CEN member into its own language and notified to the CEN Management Centre has the
same status as the official versions.
CEN members are the national standards bodies of Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland,
France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal,
Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and United Kingdom.
Recipients of this draft are invited to submit, with their comments, notification of any relevant patent rights of which they are aware and to
provide supporting documentation.
Warning : This document is not a European Standard. It is distributed for review and comments. It is subject to change without notice and
shall not be referred to as a European Standard.
EUROPEAN COMMITTEE FOR STANDARDIZATION
COMITÉ EUROPÉEN DE NORMALISATION
EUROPÄISCHES KOMITEE FÜR NORMUNG
Management Centre: rue de Stassart, 36  B-1050 Brussels
© 2008 CEN All rights of exploitation in any form and by any means reserved Ref. No. prEN 1824:2008: E
worldwide for CEN national Members.

---------------------- Page: 3 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
Contents
Foreword.3
1 Scope .4
2 Normative references .4
3 Terms and definitions .4
4 Test sites and conditions.5
5 Organization of road trials.7
6 Application of road marking materials .9
7 Measurements related to performance .11
8 Individual test report for road marking material.13
Annex A (normative) Köppen classification .14
Annex B (normative)
Measurement of the number of wheel passages and the percentage of heavy vehicles .16
Annex C (normative) Determination of applied and consummated rates of application.21
Annex D (normative) Drying time determination.23
Annex E (normative) Meteorological determinations during application.24
Annex F (normative) Removability .26
Annex G (normative) Determination of wear index.27
Annex H (informative) Model of test report.29

2

---------------------- Page: 4 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
Foreword
This document (prEN 1824:2008) has been prepared by Technical Committee CEN/TC 226 “Road equipment”, the
secretariat of which is held by AFNOR.
This document is currently submitted to the CEN Enquiry.
This document will supersede EN 1824:1998.

3

---------------------- Page: 5 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
1 Scope
This European Standard specifies the requirements for conducting road trials for road marking materials intended
for use in both permanent and temporary road marking. Details are given for test sites, for the application of road
marking materials on the test sites, for the parameters to be measured and the frequency of the measurements
and for the presentation of the results in the form of a test report.

2 Normative references

This European Standard incorporates by dated or undated reference, provisions from other publications. These
normative references are cited at the appropriate places in the text and the publications are listed hereafter. For
dated references, subsequent amendments to or revisions of any of these publications apply to this European
Standard only when incorporated in it by amendment or revision. For undated references the latest edition of the
publication referred to applies.

EN 1436, Road marking materials - Road marking performance for road users

EN 13036-1, Road and airfield surface characteristics – Test method – Part 1 : Measurements of
pavement surface macrotexture depth using volumetric patch technique

EN 13459, Road marking materials – Sampling from storage and sampling

ISO 3310-1, Test sieves - Technical requirements and testing - Part 1: Test sieves of metal wire cloth

ISO 13473-1, Characterization of pavement texture by use of surface profiles – Part 1 : Determination of
Mean Profile Depth


3 Terms and definitions

For the purpose of this standard, the following terms and definitions applies:

3.1
roll-over
the number of wheels passing over a point of a road surface within a specified period of time.

3.2
useful rate of application
-2
it corresponds to the quantity, expressed in g.m , of drop-on and/or non-drop materials which have adhered to the
road marking substrate, when lines are done.

3.3
consummated rate of application
-2
it corresponds to the quantity , expressed in g.m , of drop-on or injection materials at the exit of the guns of the
application equipment.

3.4
percentage of heavy vehicles
it corresponds to the ratio between the number of heavy vehicles and the number of all vehicles circulating on the
test site.

4

---------------------- Page: 6 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
4 Test sites and conditions

4.1 General

Test sites shall be arranged at suitable locations in accordance with 4.2 to 4.5. The test results may depend on test
field location, climate, road surface and traffic which shall be described according to clauses 4.2 to 4.6

4.2 Test sites characteristics and location
The test site shall be located in an area which belongs to one of the climatic classes defined in 4.3.

The test site shall consist of a field, where the road marking materials are to be applied, with extra space at both
ends. The roads used for test sites should be straight and flat and without junctions, substantial obstacles to
daylight, sources of frequent dirt (quarries, field exits, etc.) or tracked vehicles.

NOTE It is desirable to have additional areas at the roadsides in order to allow safe working conditions and convenient
operation of application with road marking equipment.

The percentage of heavy vehicles on the test site shall be 10% to 25% of all vehicles.

The location of the test site shall be indicated in the test report.

4.3 Climatic conditions and classes

Climatic classes (see table 1) are defined according to the Köppen classification and the use of winter
maintenance.

Köppen classification shall be determined according to Annex A.

Winter maintenance is defined by the number of of times that snowplough have operated on the test field during
the road trials. Winter maintenance is applicable if this number is equal to or greater than 20 and shall be
considered only for the Köppen zone Cfb.

Table 1 - Test Field climatic classes
Climatic Class Climatic zone according to köppen
H
C1 Dfc
E
Cfb + No Winter maintenance
C2

Cfb + Winter Maintenance
C3 Dfb
Dsb
Csa
Bsh
C4
Cfa
Csb

NOTE The influence or not of climate on the results of road trials has not yet been demonstrated.

5

---------------------- Page: 7 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
4.4 Road surface conditions and classes

Road trials shall be carried out on asphaltic road surfaces of an age of 1 year or more, which are in good condition
and not in need of repair for the duration of the road trials and are not damaged by the presence of wheel tracks,
fissures, cracks or similar. Highly porous surfaces shall be avoided.

NOTE 1 Road trials on cement concrete surfaces do not give repeatable results because of on-going chemical reactions.

NOTE 2 Road trials on highly porous surfaces do not give comparable results due to the draining properties.

At the commencement of a road trial, a road surface report of the road trial shall be available. The test surface
report shall include a general description of the road surface and an account of the texture depth (MTD : mean
texture depth), determined in accordance with EN 13036-1 :”Measurements of pavement surface macrotexture
depth using volumetric patch technique”

The MTD shall be measured at several locations on the test field. The number of measurements depends on the
test field length. Measurements shall be carried out, at least, at three transversal locations and repeated every 30m
on the test field. The transversal measurements locations are in the centre of the carriageway, near the right and
left edge line.

The averaged mean texture depth is derived from these measurements. The standard deviation shall be less than
0,15 mm.

NOTE 3 The averaged texture depth may also be directly determined in accordance with EN ISO 13473-1 “Characterization
of pavement texture by use of surface profiles – Part 1 – Determination of Mean Profile Depth”. Depending to the averaged
measured texture depth, the test field roughness is described in term of roughness class according to table 2.

Table 2 - Test field roughness classes
Roughness class Averaged measured texture depth
RG1 ≤ 0,60 mm
RG2 >0,60 mm and ≤ 0,90 mm
RG3 >0,90 mm and ≤ 1,20 mm
RG4 >1,20 mm

NOTE 4 The texture depth has an influence on the result of road trials, at least for materials applied in thin layers.

4.5 4.5 Roll-over classes

The volume of traffic shall be such as to ensure that one or more measurement areas with the desired roll-over
class can be selected (see 7.2).

At the termination of a road trial, a traffic report for the duration of the road trial should be made available. The
traffic report shall include the roll-over classes according to Table 3, determined on the measurement area(s) in
accordance with annex B.
6

---------------------- Page: 8 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
Table 3 – Roll-over classes
Roll-over class Number of wheel passages
T0
≤ 50 000
T1 Between 50 000 and 60 000
T2
100 000 ± 20 %
P0
≤ 50 000
P1 Between 50 000 and 60 000
P2 100 000 ± 20 %
P3
200 000 ± 20 %
P4
500 000 ± 20 %
P5 1 000 000 ± 20 %
P5.5
1 500 000 ± 10 %
P6
2 000 000 ± 10 %
NOTE The roll-over classes T0, T1 and T2 are for materials intended for temporary road markings, while the roll-
over classes P0, to P6 are for materials intended for permanent road markings.

The traffic report should further include the percentage of heavy vehicles together with an indication of the counting
method used.

A vehicle is considered a heavy vehicle if its maximum gross mass is above 7500 kg.

4.6 Studded tyres classes

For road trial sites where studded tyres are used to a significant degree, this shall be indicated on the test report.

NOTE From general experience, such traffic conditions can be relevant to the erosion of road markings.

5 Organization of road trials

5.1 Duration

A road trial shall include at least one full climatic cycle of one year for materials intended for permanent
road marking and up to 6 months for materials intended for temporary road marking.
In some cases test markings may fall below the performance requirements of the road authority. In these
cases, it may be necessary for the markings to be removed.

5.2 Transverse and longitudinal application patterns

5.2.1 General

Road marking materials shall be applied in patterns of lines either transverse or longitudinal to the road.
When a long (more than 30 cm) measurement area is necessary, the transverse pattern cannot be used.
When both the transverse and longitudinal patterns are used on the same test site, they shall be used on separate
parts of that test site.

5.2.2 Transverse pattern

At least three lines shall be applied for each road marking material. The distance between two adjacent lines
should be at least 0,35 m and the width at least 0,15 m as shown in figure 1. The application could be done across
one or two lanes.

NOTE Lines of the same material need not be adjacent.

7

---------------------- Page: 9 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)

Key
1 edge line 5 measurement areas
2 Lane 2 6 axis of measurement column
3 Lane 1 7 measurement column
4 road marking material in test 8 measurement points for determination of the
number of wheel passages
Figure 1 - Example of a transverse pattern showing a measurement column
5.2.3 Longitudinal pattern

Lines are applied in transverse rows and longitudinal columns. For each of the road marking materials there shall
be one line in each column containing measurement areas (see 7.2.2.3).

The lines should be at least 0,15 m wide and at least 1 m long as shown in figure 2. Unmarked space between the
lines is a maximum of 0,4 m in the transverse direction and a minimum of 0,5 m in the longitudinal direction.




8

---------------------- Page: 10 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)

Key
1 6 columns 5 axis of measurement column
2 centre line 6 Measurement areas
3 Lane 1 7 Measurement point for the determination of the
number of wheel passages
4 edge line
Figure 2 - Example of a longitudinal pattern showing a measurement column

6 Application of road marking materials

In case of longitudinal pattern, the application shall be done in the direction of the traffic.

NOTE The test results depend on various factors related to the application of the road marking materials, i.e. application
method, quantities applied, weather conditions, etc.

9

---------------------- Page: 11 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
6.1 Periods for application

Road marking materials shall be applied when the weather conditions are as defined in 6.2.

NOTE The participating parties can agree to include one or more periods for application. One period can, for instance, be
for materials intended for use as temporary road markings and another for materials intended for use as permanent road
markings. There are practical advantages to having the period(s) as short as possible.

For temporary road marking materials, the application period shall be such that the required number of wheel
passages is obtained, and the subsequent measurements carried out, prior to or after winter conditions.

6.2 Conditions suitable for application

Conditions shall be deemed suitable when:

a) the road surface appears to be dry and dew is not being formed;
b) the road surface temperature is within limits agreed upon by the participating parties;
c) the wind speed is less than the maximum agreed upon by the participating parties.

Special road marking materials can be applied in other weather conditions, which shall be noted in the individual
test report (see clause 8).

EXAMPLE The road surface temperature is at least 3 °C above the dew point of the air, the road surface
-1
temperature is between 10 °C and 50 °C and the maximum wind speed is less than 10 m·s .

6.3 Technical specification for application

Prior to the commencement of the road trials, the applicant shall submit to the test authority the application
instructions of the road marking material.

NOTE 1 The application instructions shall include preparation methods (such as how to melt a thermoplastic material),
what type of application to use (e.g. extrusion of a thermoplastic material), any particular road marking equipment required, the
pattern of application (e.g. plain or a certain type of structure), the rate(s) of application (in grams per square metre), what drop-
on materials to add, their rate(s) of application and the method to use.

Whenever possible the road marking material shall be applied using self-propelled road marking equipment, and
drop-on materials shall be applied mechanically.

NOTE 2 Most materials, except preformed materials, can be applied using self-propelled road marking equipment; this
ensures better repeatability of the application.

NOTE 3 The road marking equipment used can either be those put to general commercial use or special road marking
equipment. The road marking equipment can be operated by the usual crews or by staff at the test site.

If the test authority and the applicant agree to test road marking equipment prior to the application of a road
marking material, the rate of application of marking materials and of drop-on materials shall be adjusted and the
rate of application applied verified in accordance with annex C. A road marking equipment shall be rejected if any
of three rates of application applied in three successive test runs deviates more than 20 % from the average rate of
application.

6.4 Sampling and measurements

6.4.1 Sampling

When samples are required for identification or other purposes, each road marking material, all the components of
a multiple component material, and drop-on materials shall be taken into account.

NOTE 1 The sampling may be realized according to EN13459.

10

---------------------- Page: 12 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
NOTE 2 For materials used in more than one application, it is not necessary to sample every application.

NOTE 3 The participating parties can agree to include further specifications for sampling, such as quantities to sample.

NOTE 4 If diluents are allowed and used for the application, the rate of dilution shall be verified sampling materials both from
the original container and from the tank.

6.4.2 Measurement of drying time and weather conditions

When required by the participating parties, the drying time shall be measured for paints and cold plastics.

The drying time shall be determined in accordance with annex D for every line that contains a measurement area
(see 7.2) for further measurements.

The drying time shall be reported together with an account of the weather conditions, including the ambient
temperature, the road surface temperature, the relative air humidity and the wind speed as measured during
application in accordance with annex E.

6.4.3 Determination of the useful and consummated rates of application

During the application of a road marking material, the useful rates of application of the material and of any drop-on
or non drop-on material shall be determined in accordance with annex C. When the consummated rates application
are also required, they should be also determined in accordance with annex C.

NOTE The participating parties can agree to include a criterion for the acceptability of the application of a road marking
material. For example, the application is rejected if any of the rates of application from the different lines deviates more than 10
% from the average rate of application, or if the average rate of application deviates more than, for example, 15 % from the rate
of application given in the specification for the material.

7 Measurements related to performance

Test lines shall only be washed when it is necessary to do so and by agreements between the
participating parties. Washing shall be with a soft brush using clear water. The performance shall be then
determined once the product is dry.

7.1 Parameters
The following parameters are relevant to this standard:

a) coefficient of retroreflected luminance, R dry;
L
b) coefficient of retroreflected luminance, R wet;
L
c) coefficient of retroreflected luminance, R during rain;
L
d) luminance coefficient in diffuse illumination, Qd;
e) colour: luminance factor, β, and x,y chromaticity co-ordinates;
f) skid resistance, SRT value;
g) removability (only for removable temporary materials); may be measured if required for informative purpose
only.
h) wear index may be measured if required for informative purpose only.

The parameters a) to f) are defined in EN 1436 and shall be measured in accordance with that standard.
If required, removability shall be measured in accordance with Annex F.

If required, wear index shall be measured in accordance with Annex G.

11

---------------------- Page: 13 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
NOTE 1 For road surfaces with texture depth greater than 1,5 mm, the determination of wear index is irrelevant.
NOTE 2 The participating parties can agree which parameters to measure on the basis of the intended use of the road
marking materials.

7.2 Measurement areas
7.2.1 Roll-over classes

One or more measurement areas shall be defined in terms of roll-over in accordance with table 3 taking into
account the periodicity of measurements (see 7.4).

7.2.2 Position

7.2.2.1 Roll-over

The roll-overs shall be determined in accordance with annex B.

7.2.2.2 Transverse pattern

When introducing a measurement area, wide column along the road shall be selected (see figure 1) so that points
within the column are expected to have as close to the desired number of wheel passages as possible. The width
of the column shall be at least 0,15 m and not exceed 0,3 m.

The measurement area shall consist of at least two lines of the same road marking material.

7.2.2.3 Longitudinal pattern

When introducing a measurement area, a 0,15 m wide column along the road shall be selected (see figure 2) so
that points within the column lie within longitudinal lines and have as close to the desired number of wheel
passages as possible.

The measurement area shall consist of at least 1 m of one line of one road marking material (see figure 2).

7.3 Direction of measurements :

For transverse pattern, measurements shall be carried out in the direction of the application excepted SRT which
shall be determined in the direction of the traffic.

For longitudinal pattern, measurements shall be carried out in the direction of the application.

7.4 Number of measurements in the measurement area

One measurement shall be conducted for each of a number of measurement points evenly distributed across the
measurement area. The result shall be expressed as the average value for the different measurement points.

In the transverse pattern, a measurement area consists of at least two parts. The measuring points shall be divided
equally between each part.

For colour, β, R (dry, wet, during rain), skid resistance and Qd  measurement shall be carried out according to EN
L
1436.

For skid resistance at least two points shall be selected.

For removability it shall be tested for two of the lines on the transverse pattern, and for the first half of a line in the
longitudinal pattern in accordance with Annex F.
12

---------------------- Page: 14 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
7.5 Periodicity of measurements

The parameters shall be measured as shown in table 4 (marked ‘+’).

Table 4 - Periodicity of measurements
Initial measurements
1)
Measurements shall be
Retained measurements
taken after a minimum of 3
Retained measurements
After one or more full
days after application and
3)
Parameter
Before 6 months
4)
before a maximum of
climatic cycle
(temporary only)
2)
(permanent only)
14days and following
exposure to traffic (permanent
and temporary)
R
L (in dry, wet and
+ + +
under rain condition

when relevant)
Q
+ + +
d
Colour + + +
SRT + + +
Removability +
NOTE  Other measuring periods can be used in field trials with special purposes.
1)
On one measurement area only, preferably the one with most traffic.
2)
This limit can be extended to 30 days after application in case of justified problem like major meteorological
perturbations.
3)
On measurement areas with roll-overs T0 T1 and T2 in accordance with clause 7.
,
4)
On measurement areas with roll-overs P0, P1, P2, P3 P4, P5, P5.5 and P6 in accordance with clause 7. A full
climatic cycle is always 12 months.


8 Individual test report for road marking material

The individual test report for a road marking material shall at least include:

- the product name and similar general information,
- the intended use of the material;
- technical data for application and removability including technical specifications for materials, road marking
equipment used, drying time and rates of application (see clause 6);
- results of measurement (see clause 7);
- summary of climatic, traffic and road surface conditions for the test site and its location according to clause 4;
- % of heavy vehicle (informative).

NOTE 1 It may be appropriate to attach to the individual test report, the general report for the test site (see clause 4).

NOTE 2 A model of an individual test report is given in Annex H.



13

---------------------- Page: 15 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
Annex A
(normative)

Köppen classification

The aim of this annex is to determine in which climatic area belongs a test field using the Köppen classification
system.

A.1 Generalities
The Köppen Climate Classification System is the most widely used for classifying the world's climates. It defines six
major climate types based on annual and monthly averages of temperature and precipitation. Each type is
designated by a capital letter (A, B, C, D, E and H).

Further sub-types, designated by a second lower case letter (f, m, s or w), were established to distinguish specific
seasonal characteristics of temperature and precipitation.

To further denote variations in climate a third lower letter (a, b, c, d, h or k) was added.

Clauses A.2 to A.5 present the different steps that shall be used to determine the Köppen climate type from
meteorological data measured closed to the test field. Temperature and rainfall parameters have to be derived from
the last 30 years.
A.2 Step 1 : Determine whether a climate is arid/semiarid (climate B)
A.2.1 Determine the annual rainfall r (in mm) and the annual average temperature t (in °C).

A.2.2 If r > 20 (t+14) it is not a climate B. Go to A.3.

A.2.3 Determine the rainfall distribution. Then determine Bs, Bw or neither according to the criteria given in table
A.1 below.
Table A.1
Not a B climate
Bs (Semi-arid) Bw (Arid)
Rainfall Distribution
Go to A.3
70% of rainfall in warmest 6
r > 20(t+14) 10(t+14) months
70% of rainfall in coldest 6
r > 20 x t 10 x t months
Even rainfall distribution
r > 20 x (t+7) 10 x (t+7) (neither of above)
A.3 Step 2 : If not a B Climate, identify the climate as A, C, D or E according to
temperature data
The climate is determine according to temperature of coldest (t ) and/or warmest month (t ).
min max

14

---------------------- Page: 16 ----------------------
oSIST prEN 1824:2009
prEN 1824:2008 (E)
A.3.1 if t > 18°C, it is an A climate
min

A.3.2 if 3° ≤ t ≤ 18°C and t > 10°C, it is a C climate
min max

A.3.3 if t < 3°C and t > 10°C, it is a D climate
min max

A.3.4 if t < 10°C, it is a E climate
max
A.4 Step 3 : After identifying A, Bs, Bs, C, D or E, determine the climate subcategories
A.4.1 A climates

Consider the avera
...

Questions, Comments and Discussion

Ask us and Technical Secretary will try to provide an answer. You can facilitate discussion about the standard in here.