CLC/TR 50417:2016

Safety of household and similar electrical appliances - Interpretations related to European Standards in the EN 60335 series

This Technical Report includes all the interpretations agreed up to the CLC/TC 61 meeting in December 2015. It includes all Interpretations currently in force made by CENELEC TC 61 on EN 60335 series of standards. It also includes all decision sheets in force made by OSM/HA. Both types of interpretations are clearly identified. Interpretations relating to a particular standard are listed together, the Parts 2 of EN 60335 being associated with the appropriate edition of Part 1. For each standard, the interpretations are listed in the order of clauses and subclauses. Each CENELEC TC 61 interpretation is identified by: - the place and date of the meeting when it was agreed; - the document number of the minutes of the meeting; - the number of the reference document, when applicable; - a code with the format YYYY/XX, where YYYY is the year when the interpretation was decided, XX is the number of the interpretation, restarted every year. Each OSM/HA decision sheet is identified through the following template (...).

Sicherheit elektrischer Geräte für den Hausgebrauch und ähnliche Zwecke – Auslegungen zu Europäischen Normen der Reihe EN 60335

Sécurité des appareils électrodomestiques et analogues - Interprétations relatives aux Normes Européennes de la série EN 60335

Varnost gospodinjskih in podobnih električnih aparatov - Razlage v zvezi z evropskimi standardi skupine EN 60335

To tehnično poročilo vključuje vse trenutno veljavne razlage tehničnega odbora CENELEC TC 61 v zvezi s skupino standardov EN 60335. Vključuje tudi vse veljavne liste z odločitvami, ki jih je sprejel OSM/HA.

General Information

• Status: Published
• Publication Date: 22-Sep-2016
• ICS: 97.030 - Domestic electrical appliances in general
• Technical Committee: CLC/TC 61 - Safety of household and similar electrical appliances
• Drafting Committee: CLC/TC 61 - Safety of household and similar electrical appliances
• Current Stage: 6060 - Document made available - Publishing
• Start Date: 23-Sep-2016
• Completion Date: 23-Sep-2016
• Ref Project: SIST-TP CLC/TR 50417:2017 - Safety of household and similar electrical appliances - Interpretations related to European Standards in the EN 60335 series

Relations

• Replaces: CLC/TR 50417:2014 - Safety of household and similar electrical appliances - Interpretations related to European Standards in the EN 60335 series
• Effective Date: 26-Jan-2023
• Referred By: EN 60335-1:2012/A13:2017 - Household and similar electrical appliances - Safety - Part 1: General requirements
• Effective Date: 03-Feb-2026

Overview

CLC/TR 50417:2016 is a CENELEC Technical Report compiling official interpretations and decision sheets relating to the EN 60335 series - the European standards for the safety of household and similar electrical appliances. This report gathers all interpretations agreed up to the CLC/TC 61 meeting in December 2015 and identifies which are CENELEC TC 61 interpretations and which are OSM/HA decision sheets. Interpretations are organized by Part 1 editions and associated Parts 2, and then by clause and subclause.

Key topics and requirements

The Technical Report does not add new technical requirements but clarifies application and testing of existing EN 60335 requirements. Key topics covered include:

• Scope and organization of EN 60335 interpretations: how Parts 2 are associated with the correct edition of Part 1 and how interpretations are identified (meeting, document number, year/code).
• Testing and assessment clarifications, e.g. treatment of motor capacitors, cord-reel testing with wet cords, and measurement considerations during Clause 19 tests.
• Insulation and capacitor guidance, e.g. class II insulation arrangements and acceptable combinations of Y1/Y2 capacitors.
• Marking, controls and connectors, e.g. marking of push‑push mains switches, interchangeability constraints for plugs/socket‑outlets and connectors, and acceptance rules for controls complying with EN 60730.
• Specific appliance interpretations across Parts 2: the contents list shows interpretations for many appliance types (irons, dishwashers, ovens, washing machines, heaters, microwaves, range hoods, compressors, dryers, air cleaners, etc.).
• Safety-related warnings and instructions, e.g. requirements for appliances incorporating UVC emitters and manufacturer declarations for UV resistance.
• Administrative details: identification templates for OSM/HA decision sheets and a code format (YYYY/XX) for CENELEC TC 61 interpretations.

Applications and who uses it

CLC/TR 50417:2016 is a practical reference for:

• Product designers and manufacturers of household electrical appliances seeking consistent interpretation of EN 60335 provisions.
• Test laboratories and conformity assessment bodies applying EN 60335 tests and needing authoritative clarifications.
• Certification bodies and notified bodies that assess compliance and issue certifications.
• Standards committees and technical experts (CENELEC TC 61 and national committees) using established decisions to harmonize application across countries.
• Regulatory and compliance professionals preparing documentation, instructions for use, and safety markings.

Related standards

This report cross‑references and aligns with standards frequently used alongside EN 60335, for example:

• EN 60335‑1 and multiple EN 60335‑2 Parts (see table of contents in the report)
• IEC 60252 (motor capacitors), IEC 60730 (controls), IEC/TR 60083, IEC 60320, IEC 60309, IEC 60884‑1, IEC 60127

CLC/TR 50417 is a consolidated, authoritative source for consistent interpretation of appliance safety requirements under the EN 60335 family.

Standards Content (Sample)

SLOVENSKI STANDARD
01-september-2017
1DGRPHãþD
SIST-TP CLC/TR 50417:2014
9DUQRVWJRVSRGLQMVNLKLQSRGREQLKHOHNWULþQLKDSDUDWRY5D]ODJHY]YH]L]
HYURSVNLPLVWDQGDUGLVNXSLQH(1
Safety of household and similar electrical appliances - Interpretations related to
European Standards in the EN 60335 series
Sécurité des appareils électrodomestiques et analogues - Interprétations relatives aux
Normes Européennes de la série EN 60335
Ta slovenski standard je istoveten z: CLC/TR 50417:2016
ICS:
13.120 Varnost na domu Domestic safety
97.030 (OHNWULþQLDSDUDWL]DGRPQD Domestic electrical
VSORãQR appliances in general
2003-01.Slovenski inštitut za standardizacijo. Razmnoževanje celote ali delov tega standarda ni dovoljeno.

TECHNICAL REPORT CLC/TR 50417

RAPPORT TECHNIQUE
TECHNISCHER BERICHT
September 2016
ICS 97.030 Supersedes CLC/TR 50417:2014
English Version
Safety of household and similar electrical appliances -
Interpretations related to European Standards in the EN 60335
series
Sécurité des appareils électrodomestiques et analogues - Sicherheit elektrischer Geräte für den Hausgebrauch und
Interprétations relatives aux Normes Européennes de la ähnliche Zwecke - Auslegungen zu Europäischen Normen
série EN 60335 der Reihe EN 60335

This Technical Report was approved by CENELEC on 2016-07-04.

CENELEC members are the national electrotechnical committees of Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, the Czech Republic,
Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia,
Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland,
Turkey and the United Kingdom.

European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization
Comité Européen de Normalisation Electrotechnique
Europäisches Komitee für Elektrotechnische Normung
CEN-CENELEC Management Centre: Avenue Marnix 17, B-1000 Brussels
© 2016 CENELEC All rights of exploitation in any form and by any means reserved worldwide for CENELEC Members.
Ref. No. CLC/TR 50417:2016 E
Contents Page
European foreword . 4
1 Scope . 5
2 EN 60335-1:1994, General requirements . 6
3 EN 60335-1:2002, General requirements . 9
4 EN 60335-1:2012, General requirements . 21
5 EN 60335-2-3:2002/A11:2010, Electric irons . 23
6 EN 60335-2-5:2003, Dishwashers . 24
7 EN 60335-2-6:2003, Cooking ranges, hobs and ovens . 25
8 EN 60335-2-6:2003/A11:2010, Cooking ranges, hobs and ovens . 28
9 EN 60335-2-6:2003/A13:2013, Cooking ranges, hobs and ovens . 30
10 EN 60335-2-7:2003, Washing machines . 31
11 EN 60335-2-8:2003, Shavers, hair clippers, etc. . 33
12 EN 60335-2-9:2003, Toasters, grills, etc. . 34
13 EN 60335-2-9:2003/A13:2010, Grills, toasters and similar portable cooking appliances . 37
14 EN 60335-2-13:2003+ A1:2004, Deep fat fryers, frying pans and similar appliances . 38
15 EN 60335-2-14:2006, Electric kitchen machines . 39
16 EN 60335-2-15:2002, Appliances for heating liquids . 44
17 EN 60335-2-17:2002 Blankets, pads and similar flexible heating appliances . 46
18 EN 60335-2-21:2003 Storage water heaters . 47
19 EN 60335-2-23:2003, Appliances for skin or hair care . 49
20 EN 60335-2-23:2003/A11:2010 Appliances for skin or hair care . 50
21 EN 60335-2-25:2002/A11:2010, Microwave ovens, including combination microwave ovens51
22 EN 60335-2-27:2003, UV appliances . 52
23 EN 60335-2-29:2004, Battery chargers . 53
24 EN 60335-2-30:2009/A11:2012, Room heaters . 54
25 EN 60335-2-30:2009, Room heaters . 55
26 EN 60335-2-31:2003, Range hoods . 56
27 EN 60335-2-31:2003 + A1:2006 + A2:2009, Range hoods . 57
28 EN 60335-2-34:2002 , Motor-compressors . 59
29 EN 60335-2-43:2003, Clothes dryers and towel rails . 60
30 EN 60335-2-52:2003, Oral hygiene appliances . 61
31 EN 60335-2-60:2003, Whirlpools . 62
32 EN 60335-2-65:2003+A1:2008, Air-cleaning appliances . 63
33 EN 60335-2-71:2003+A1:2008, heating appliances for breeding and rearing animals . 64
34 EN 60335-2-75:2004, Commercial dispensing appliances and vending machines . 65
35 EN 60335-2-76:2005/A12:2010, Fence energizers . 66
36 EN 60335-2-82:2003, amusement machines and personal service machines . 67
37 EN 60335-2-89:2002, Commercial refrigerating appliances . 68
38 EN 60335-2-90:2002, Commercial microwave ovens . 69
Annex A (informative) Collection of interpretations of the requirement for vulnerable people in

7.10 of EN 60335-1:2012 and different Parts 2 . 70
Annex B (informative) Interpretations withdrawn in this edition of CLC/TR 50417. 73

European foreword
This document (CLC/TR 50417:2016) has been prepared by Technical Committee CLC/TC 61, "Safety of
household and similar appliances".
This document is currently submitted to voting in accordance with the Internal Regulations, Part 2,
Subclause 11.4.3.3 (simple majority) for acceptance as a CENELEC Technical Report.
This document supersedes CLC/TR 50417:2014.
Attention is drawn to the possibility that some of the elements of this document may be the subject of
patent rights. CENELEC shall not be held responsible for identifying any or all such patent rights.
1 Scope
This Technical Report includes all the interpretations agreed up to the CLC/TC 61 meeting in December
2015.
It includes all Interpretations currently in force made by CENELEC TC 61 on EN 60335 series of
standards. It also includes all decision sheets in force made by OSM/HA. Both types of interpretations are
clearly identified. Interpretations relating to a particular standard are listed together, the Parts 2 of
EN 60335 being associated with the appropriate edition of Part 1. For each standard, the interpretations
are listed in the order of clauses and subclauses.
Each CENELEC TC 61 interpretation is identified by:
— the place and date of the meeting when it was agreed;
— the document number of the minutes of the meeting;
— the number of the reference document, when applicable;
— a code with the format YYYY/XX, where
YYYY is the year when the interpretation was decided,
XX is the number of the interpretation, restarted every year.
Each OSM/HA decision sheet is identified through the following template:
DECISION SHEET Date
YYYY-MM-DD
Standard EN 60335-X OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date

… … … …
Attention is drawn to the possibility that some of the elements of this document may be the subject of
patent rights. CEN and CENELEC shall not be held responsible for identifying any or all such patent
rights.
2 EN 60335-1:1994, General requirements
1995/01 – General Dublin, May 1995, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1027
CLC/TC 61(FR)292
In class II constructions of appliances it is not allowed to reverse the basic and the supplementary
insulation.
1996/01 - General Copenhagen, May 1996, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1075
CLC/TC 61(SEC)1000
For testing motor capacitors in appliances under the scope of EN 60335, document IEC 61/1055/CD
should be used.
1996/02 – General Athens, November 1996, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1098

CLC/TC 61(SEC)1087
The mass of the appliance is to be considered with the empty appliance, if nothing is said in the particular
standard or for a particular clause.
1998/01 - General Brussels, May 1998, CLC/TC61(SEC)1185
Controls are considered to comply with EN 60730 if they complied with the previous relevant standard
before the dow specified in EN 60730, and may be used in an appliance until the end of the certification
period.
NOTE 1 Controls will also have to comply with the applicable requirements of EN 60335 series standards.
2000/01 - General Kristiansand, June 2000, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1287
The word “similar” in the title “Toxicity and similar hazards” means other hazards, which may be
applicable but not covered by the standard.
2000/02 - General Brussels, October 2000, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1302
Concerning the use of socket-outlets on appliances, those should be of the appropriate type as specified
in IEC/TR 60083:1997 for the relevant countries.
1998/02 - Clause 1 Naples, November 1998, CLC/TC61(SEC)1218
The scope of EN 60335-1:1994 is meant to include the safety of operators which are instructed to operate
the machine, but which are non electrical experts.
1996/03 - Subclause 15.1.2 Copenhagen, May 1996, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1075

CLC/TC 61(SE)351
Parts which are to be removed in accordance with the instructions for use and which can be removed
only with the aid of a tool, shall not be removed, only for the purpose of the test of 15.1.2.
2002/01 - Subclause 19.13 Brussels, November 2002, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1403
CLC/TC 61(IT)258
In general, creepage distances and clearances are not measured during and after the tests of Clause 19.
1997/01 - Subclause 22.33 Edinburgh, May 1997, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1127
CLC/TC 61(SE)393
Add the following note:
NOTE 2 An air layer is not considered sufficient as one of the layers of double insulation, if it is likely that the air
layer could be bridged by leaking liquid".
1996/04 - Subclause 22.42 Athens, November 1996, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1098
CLC/TC 61(AT)260
Concerning Y2 capacitors used as protective impedance, the following applies for bridging insulations:
a) Two Y2 capacitors (voltage proof 1 500 V, Not accepted. Acceptance for two Y2
peak impulse 5 kV); combination Y2 (basic capacitors with voltage proof 2 500 V only
insulation) + Y2 (supplementary insulation)
b) Combination Y1 (basic insulation) + Y2 Accepted for Y2 capacitors with voltage proof
(supplementary insulation) 2 500 V only
c) Combination Y2 (basic insulation) + Y1 Accepted (idem b)
(supplementary insulation)
d) Combination of three Y2 capacitors in series Not accepted

1995/02 - Subclause 24.1.1 Dublin, May 1995, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1027
CLC/TC 61(SEC)995
Miniature fuses with other ratings or dimensions than those in the EN 60127 series can be accepted
under the following conditions:
— It shall not be possible to change the fuse without removing a cover with the use of a tool.
— The fuse and the fuseholder shall be marked to ensure correct replacement.
— The fuse shall be checked in the appliance; 10 samples shall break reliably under fault conditions.
1994/01 - Subclause 24.1.2, note 2 Oslo, April 1994, CLC/TC 61(SEC)972
The switching part of an automatic control (or programmer) with an off position is considered as a switch.
An endurance test is only necessary if such a switch is required by the standard.
2001/01 - Subclause 25.7 Delft, May 2001, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1330
The words « shall not be lighter than » means that any heavier standardized cord can be used.
2001/02 - Subclause 25.22 Paris, November 2001, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1349
CLC/TC 61(SEC)1334
Replace the second dashed item by:
— be located so that the connector can be inserted into the correct engagement position without
difficulty and that improper engagement is not readily possible;
1999/01 - Subclause 26.10 Pamplona, June 1999, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1244
CLC/TC 61(DK)123
This subclause does not apply to earth terminals.
1992/01 - Subclause 30.2 Pettenasco, September 1992, CLC/TC 61(SEC)869
"not likely to be ignited" belongs to decorative trims, knobs and other parts.
2000/03 - Annex ZD Kristiansand, June 2000, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1287
CLC/TC 61(SEC)1257
Clause 29 has to be mentioned instead of 29.1 with regard to distances, because 29.2 (distance through
insulation) is also involved.
3 EN 60335-1:2002, General requirements
2013/06 - Subclause 7.10 Brussels, November 2013, CLC/TC 61(SEC)2024 + CH NC comments
Audible feedback is any audible response got immediately after the operation of the switch.
2004/01 - Subclause 15.1.2 Milan, November 2004, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1519
Addition:
Appliances with an automatic cord reel are tested with the cord in the most unfavourable position in such
a way that the reeling of the wet cord may affect electrical insulation during operation. The cord shall not
be dried before reeling.
2006/01 - Subclause 20.2 Málaga, June 2006, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1567
Replace note 1 by the following normative text:
For appliances having dangerous movable parts, due to their main function, e.g. the needle of a sewing
machine, tools of kitchen machines or the blade of an electrical knife, a full protection is not suitable for
intended use.
2013/07 - Subclause 21.1 Brussels, November 2013, CLC/TC 61(SEC)2024 + CH NC comments
Sub-clause 21.1 is applicable to any parts of the enclosure irrespective of the material they are made of.
Damage to the finish, ragged or sharp surfaces, small dents are not examined according to sub-clause
22.14, as this sub-clause is only dealing to the state of the appliance in normal use.
2002/05 - Clause 24 Kista, May 2002, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1377
CLC/TC 61(FR)1351
Add the following paragraph:
Plugs and socket-outlets and other connecting devices of interconnection cords shall not be
interchangeable with plugs and socket-outlets listed in IEC/TR 60083 or IEC 60906-1 or with connectors
and appliance inlets complying with the standard sheets of IEC 60320-1, if direct supply to these parts
from the supply mains could give rise to a hazard.
2005/01 - Subclause 24.1 Brussels, November 2005, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1544
Plugs and connectors specified in IEC 60083, IEC 60320, IEC 60309 or IEC 60884-1 are not Subjected to
the tests of EN 60335-1.
2010/01 - Subclause 24.1 Brussels, June 2010, CLC/TC 61(DE)0615/INF
For motor-run capacitors (IEC 60252 type P2) with a metal housing having an overpressure fuse the
flame testing of internal plastic parts as required in 30.2.2 and 30.2.3.1 is not necessary.
2004/02 - Subclause 24.1.3 Milan, November 2004, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1519
For the purpose of this test a thermostat or timer that is operating the relay or contactor is considered to
be a switch.
2011/12 – Subclause 25.7 Malta, December 2011, CLC/TC 61(IT)0278/DC
Cable 03RNH2-F, not harmonized at CENELEC level but covered by a testing schedule developed by EU
certification bodies, or a harmonized cable with similar characteristics, can be used for appliances for
which 05RNH2-F is allowed.
2005/03 - Clause 32 Brussels, November 2005, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1544
Málaga, June 2006, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1567

For appliances incorporating UVC emitters no exposure to UVA, UVB or UVC is allowed during operation.
NOTE Examples of appliances that may incorporate UVC emitters are range hoods, water pumps, air cleaners.
The manufacturer declaration is considered as sufficient proof that the plastic material exposed to the
radiation is UV resistant.
The instructions shall include the substance of the following:
WARNING This appliance contains a UV emitter. Do not stare at the light source.
During maintenance and service the UVC emitters shall be switched off completely by a plug or switch. If
this does not switch off completely the UVC emitters, an interlock is needed. It shall not be possible to
operate the interlock switch with the test finger.
2007/01 – Annex I, Subclause 19.101 Berlin, November 2007, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1613
The appliance is operated under normal operation.
When any of the fault conditions are simulated, the duration of the test is as specified in Subclause 19.7.
DECISION SHEET Date
1998-02-11
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
7.10 8 11.1
7.10 20 6.3 (SE)01/06
7.10 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Marking
Problem
Marking of push-push mains switch
Decision
A push-push mains switch for stationary appliances needs a visual means e.g. according to IEC 60417
"Graphical symbols for use on equipment" or a lamp to indicate clearly whether the switch is in the on/off
position. The marking should be on or near the switch.
When the visual mean according IEC 60417 is used, it shall be distinguished clearly the different switch
positions using a lamp or a similar means.
Comment
CLC/TC 61 decision of April 1994.
th rd
This decision has been updated after the 20 and 23 OSM/HA meetings.
NOTE This will be withdrawn at the dow of EN 60335-1:2012, i.e. 2014-11-21

DECISION SHEET Date
1998-02-24
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
8 11 9.2 (NO)1/97
20 11 9.2 (NO)1/97
8 & 20 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Protection against electric shock
Problem
Should the tests on for instance a portable fan heater with an enclosure of plastic material be carried out
in cold condition or in steady state condition ?
Decision
Normal use means room temperature, not steady state condition.
Comment
CLC/TC 61 confirmed (May 1998).
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
DECISION SHEET Date
2000-08-31
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
8 & 20 14 9.2 (SI)1/00
8 & 20 15 6.3 (Chair)1/01
8 & 20 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
SECRETARY’s NOTE: CLC TC 61 agreed that the following OSM/HA decision 249 also applies to
clause 22.
Subject
Interlock switches
Problem
For removing or opening a cover, a door, etc., mechanically operated interlock switches can be used for
protection against electric shock and accessibility of moving parts.
Which are the requirements for interlock switches regarding distances contact gaps and reliability of
cycling operations of switches for fixed appliances and appliances provided with plug which provide:
1) protection against electric shock and energy hazards, or
2) protection against dangerous moving parts ?
Decision
1) It is not acceptable to get access to live parts after operation of an interlock switch without a tool
even if is at least 3 mm between the contact gaps and with all poles disconnection. In that situation it
is still considered to be live. Only for certain Parts 2 (e.g. air cleaners and insect killers) this is
allowed.
2) At least a micro switch (< 3 mm) and minimum one pole disconnection to obtain the protection
against mechanical hazards.
The interlock switches are tested according to 24.1.3:
switched under load for 10 000 cycles, switched without load for 100 cycles.
Comment
CLC/TC 61confirmed in May 2001.
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
DECISION SHEET Date 2015-04-23
Standard EN 60335-1:2012 + Amd.
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
th
24.1.4 29 OSMHA 5.1.5. OSM HA
BE01/2015
Sweden
Question
24.1.4 The relevant standard for automatic controls is IEC 60730-1 together with the relevant part 2.
The number of cycles of operation for automatic controls that operate during the test of Clause 11 need
not be declared for 6.10 and 6.11 of IEC 60730-1, if the appliance meets the requirements of this
standard when they are short-circuited. Does this mean that a appliance which meets the requirement of
19.4 (short-circuit of the automatic control) the automatic control needs not to be verified according
§24.1.4? What about a electronic circuit with a relay for the switching action? If complies with 19.14, does
it then need to be retested acc. 24.1.4? We have an electronic circuit as thermal regulation for §11. We
have performed 19.4 and 19.14, which short-circuits the automatic control (required in the standard).
Does the above mean we do not have to check 24.1.4? Is 24.1.4 only applicable for appliance where
§19.4 is not applicable?
OSM/HA Decision
Cycles in §24.1.4 in general are not applicable for electronic circuits (except to the relays incorporated).
When applicable, the number of cycles of operation for automatic controls that operate during the test of
Clause 11 need not be tested as requested for 6.10 and 6.11 of IEC 60730-1, if the appliance meets the
requirements of this standard when they are short-circuited.
“The requirements of this standard” written in the above means complete standard (incl. §11). If the
appliance pass §11 and the other standard clauses with the control short-circuited, no requirements for
cycles are applicable.
Decision
Cycles in §24.1.4 in general are not applicable for electronic circuits (except to the relays incorporated).
When applicable, the number of cycles of operation for automatic controls that operate during the test of
Clause 11 need not be tested as requested for 6.10 and 6.11 of IEC 60730-1, if the appliance meets the
requirements of this standard when they are short-circuited.
“The requirements of this standard” written in the above means complete standard (incl. §11). If the
appliance pass §11 and the other standard clauses with the control short-circuited, no requirements for
cycles are applicable.
Comment
CLC/TC 61confirmed in December 2015.
DECISION SHEET Date
2002-07-10
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
26.5 15 9.15 (SI)01/01
26.5 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Terminals
Problem
Which of the two figures shows the correct way to carry out the test of stranded conductor ?
Decision
Figure 2 shows the correct way to carry out the test.
Comment
CLC/TC 61 confirmed (November 2001).
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.

DECISION SHEET Date
2002-07-11
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
29.1 15 9.19 (CH)04/01
29.1 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
SECRETARY’s NOTE: CLC TC 61 agreed that the following OSM/HA decision 305 can be deleted.
Subject
Creepage/clearance
Problem
What is the minimum value for creepage distances and clearances on the printed circuit between the
printed conductor for live part and the printed conductor for SELV, considering that a printed earthing
conductor there is between the two printed conductors ?
Decision
The value prescribed for basic insulation is required, depending on the protection against deposition of
dirt,
The printed earthing conductor shall fulfil the requirements of 27.6.
Comment
CLC/TC 61 confirmed (November 2001).
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
DECISION SHEET Date
2005-07-27
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
11 18 5.6 (NL)02/04
11 19 4.3 CLCTC61(SEC)1519
11 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Heating
Problem
How to deal with appliances which may be used in accordance to the instructions at high temperatures
(45 °C) ?
Decision
If a manufacturer declares an ambient temperature exceeding 25 °C, all the heating tests shall be done at
an ambient temperature of (23 ± 2) °C but the limit should be reduced as the difference between the
declared temperature and 25 °C. This decision is based on Note 2 of Table 3 of Clause 11 of Part 1.
Comment
CLC/TC 61 confirmed (November 2004).
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
DECISION SHEET Date
2005-07-27
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
15.1.2 18 5.11 (SI)04/04
15.1.2 19 4.3 CLCTC61(SEC)1519
15.1.2 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Moisture resistance
Problem
The testing of appliances with (automatic) cord reels is performed in the most unfavourable positions of
the cord reel, in position of an appliance as defined in 15.1.2.
As the standard does not taking into account influence of water entrance during the reeling of wet cord,
shall the cable be dried during the high voltage test ?
Decision
The cable shall not be dried during the test.
Comment
CLC/TC 61 confirmed (November 2004).
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
DECISION SHEET Date
2006-07-07
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
29.3 20 5.3 (GB)01/05
29.3 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
SECRETARY’s NOTE: CLC TC 61 agreed that the following OSM/HA decision 376 can be deleted.
Subject
Distance
Problem
Subclause 29.3 states the requirements for the thickness of solid insulation do not apply to inaccessible
insulation providing the other requirements stated within the subclause are met.
The question is about a product where a thin insulation sheet used within the product met the
requirements of the standard for inaccessible insulation once the product had been installed. However,
during installation the inaccessible insulation is accessible and, although electrically the insulation meets
the requirements, mechanically we found it could be easily damaged.
The product is an instantaneous water heater that is permanently plumbed into the water supply and
electrically connected to fixed wiring. A professional competent person normally installs the product.
The question is if this insulation is adequate even if it can easily be accidentally damaged but meets the
requirements of the standard if it is not considered an accessible part.
Decision
Taking into account the definition of accessible part (3.6.3) and the test of 21.2, if there is a risk of
insulation damage, the scratch test shall be performed on the insulation which is accessible during
installation.
Comment
CLC/TC 61 confirmed in November 2005.
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
DECISION SHEET Date
2006-07-07
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
30.2 20 5.3 (ES)05/05
30.2 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Glow-wire
Problem
Considering 30.2 of Part 1, including A2, how shall the glow wire test on motor capacitors and in which
parts be performed ?
The photo 1 shows a resin embedded motor capacitors where the internal connection between the wire
and the plate is a soldered one.
The photos 2 and 3 show the points of connection on the upper and lower part.
In all the figures the connections are within 3 mm form the external plastic case of the capacitor.
Decision
The glow wire test has to be performed over the shielding and shielded materials joint together, where the
connection is made, at 750 °C, from the inside to outside as normal testing, allowing the tip to penetrate
in the shielded material. In this case, the shielded material is the external plastic case because is within
3 mm from the connection (as in the figures).
Comment
CLC/TC 61 confirmed in November 2005 and June 2006.
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
DECISION SHEET Date
2007-08-03
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
19 & 29 20 10.2 (DE)01/06
19 & 29 21 7 (SEC)02/07
19 & 29 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
SECRETARY’s NOTE: CLC TC 61 agreed that the following OSM/HA decision 398 can be deleted.
Subject
Abnormal operation
Problem
During the CLC/TC 61 meeting in Milan in November 2005 the situation for the motor protectors was
discussed and it was agreed that the requirements in accordance to Clause 29 will not be applied
because the contacts are only opened during the tests of Clause 19. It was discussed to apply only a high
voltage test with the double of the working voltage across the functional insulation.
But in the opinion of the OSM/HA delegates, the component standard distances for functional insulation
applies only to the protector itself and Clause 29 of EN 60335 should apply to connections, or tracks, or
other parts of the protection circuits.
Decision
The requirements of EN 60730 apply to the motor protector itself, for all other parts of the protection
circuit the requirements of EN 60335 apply.
Comment
CLC/TC 61 agreed (November 2006).
This opinion was already confirmed by IEC/TC61 as indicated in Item 33a of the Jeju meeting minutes
(document 61/3211/RM) concerning inquiry USA1 and is also in line with IEC/TC 61/MT 23 opinion.
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
DECISION SHEET Date
2007-08-03
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
25.15 20 10.4 (DE)02/06
25.15 21 6 (SEC)02/07
25.15 22 5.2.1 (SEC)04/08
25.15 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Detachable supply cords
Problem
How shall the test of 25.15 be performed in case of fixed appliances intended to be permanently
connected to fixed wiring having a mass between 1 and 4 kg?
Decision
Fixed appliances have to be tested like appliances > 4 kg, according to 25.15 (100 N and 0,35 Nm),
independently of the weight of the appliance, and supply cables insulation (according to 25.8) shall
correspond to the weight of the appliance.
This decision is not applicable if the cable is not accessible in normal use (e.g. the supply cable to motor
drives in the scope of EN 60335-2-95, 2-97 and 2-103).
Comment
CLC/TC 61 agreed (November 2006 and June 2007).
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting
DECISION SHEET Date
2007-08-03
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
3.8.2 21 6.4 (ES)02/07
3.8.2 22 5.2.1 (SEC)04/08
3.8.2 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Definitions
Problem
Based on the definition in 3.8.2 and taking into account that there is not always a stand-by position
marked or identified in the appliance operation and there is a need to differentiate the "off" and "stand-by"
circuits, at least in the test of 19.11.2 and 22.46 in the appliance in which 19.11.2 is applicable in stand–
by mode according to the relevant Parts 2.
We would like to know if the stand-by circuit include those parts that are energized when the appliance is
in "0" position.
Decision
In stand-by, only electronic components that are energized in any of their terminals are susceptible to be
short circuited according to a) to g) in 19.11.2.
It was agreed that in terms of clause 19 the meaning of "off" correspond to circuits or components that
are not energized in any of their terminals.
Comment
CLC/TC 61, MT 23 and IEC/TC 61 confirmed that for Part 1 at this time 19.11.2 does not apply to stand-
by circuits.
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
DECISION SHEET Date
2008-07-10
Standard EN 60335-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
27.1 21 8.6 (IT)06/07
27.1 22 5.3 CLCTC61(SEC)1625
27.1 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Earthing
Problem
We would like to raise the matter in order to have a common decision if a wire for earthing contact as
shown by the photos is acceptable or not considering the present standard that does not give any
supplementary requirement in 27.1 for special prepared conductors.
Decision
The crimping system for the protective conductor as shown in the photo can be accepted, since the
insulation is not required to be always present on the protective earthing conductor.
Comment
Confirmed by CLC/TC 61 (November 2007)
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.

DECISION SHEET Date
1998-02-24
Standard EN 60335-2-1:2002 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
8.2 12 6.1.4 (IT)7/98
8.2 13 4 (Chair/Ljubl)2/99
8.2 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Protection against electric shock
Problem
Interpretation of 8.2 on fluorescent lamps located behind detachable cover.
Decision
1) The Standard has to be met. In class II construction it is not allowed to touch basic insulation.
2) If a tool is needed to removed the cover (it is considered detachable if there is an instruction
according to 2.7.2) the basic insulation may be accessible after removal of the cover.
Comment
1) CLC/TC 61 confirmed the decision (June 1999).
th
2) After discussion in 13 OSM/HA meeting
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
4 EN 60335-1:2012, General requirements
2013/02 - Subclause 7.10 Dublin, June 2013, TC61_*(SE)0005/Q
Devices used to start/stop operational functions of the appliance, if any, shall be distinguished from other
manual devices by means of shape, or size or surface, texture or position etc.
According to our understanding, a push-push button switch used for start and stop the operation cannot
be used to also change the motor speed.
2013/03 - Subclause 7.10 Dublin, June 2013, TC61_ *(NO)0001_2013/Q
The click of the switch (considering e.g. the situation on thermostats for irons) can be accepted provided
that it is originated inside the switch that is operated and can be distinguished at a distance of 77 cm (as
in Guide 29, Figure 2, arms reach for adults) from the switch.
2013/04 - Subclause 7.10 Dublin, June 2013, TC61_FR_0002_2013_Q
Constructions with switches that have two different stable positions (meaning that it can be seen or felt
when they have been pressed or rotated).are in compliance with the requirement in 7.10 relating to tactile
feedback.
2013/06 - Subclause 7.10 Brussels, November 2013, CLC/TC 61(SEC)2024 + CH NC
comments
Audible feedback is any audible response got immediately after the operation of the switch.
2015/01, Subclause 7.10 Brussels, June/July 2015, TC61/NL/00002/NCP (12b agenda
item)
A push-push button switch used for start and stop the operation shall not be used for other functions such
as changing the motor speed.
For hand held appliances with rated input 50 W or lower it is acceptable to have a push-push button for
different functions including on / off if there is an immediate feedback to the user e.g. by motion/vibration
or visual plus audible.
2015/02, Subclause 7.10 Brussels, June/July 2015, CLC/TC 61 (SEC)2150 (12a agenda item)
The click of a switch can be accepted as an audible feedback provided that it is originated inside the
switch that is operated and can be heard at a distance of 77 cm from the switch.
2014/01 - Subclause 7.12. Z1 Stresa, June 2014, WG 4 Convenor Report
Also see Item 14 Dublin 2013 minutes

It is acceptable to provide the specific instructions related to safe operation in a separate Safety Booklet.
On the first page of the Instruction Booklet, it shall state that the Safety instructions shall be read before
using the appliance. It is also acceptable to have separate booklets for maintenance, scrapping, etc.
In case the instructions are in different sections (e.g. for installation, first use, use, maintenance,
treatment at end of life, etc), it is also acceptable that the safety instructions specific for each section are
indicated at the start of the relevant section. Such instructions shall be fully in compliance with 7.12.Z1
(e.g. the height of the characters, measured on the capital letters, shall be at least 3 mm).
2014/02 - Subclause 7.12 Stresa, June 2014, WG 4 Convenor Report
(As given in 7.12 of this standard) includes 7.12.1, 7.12.2, etc…
When the instructions relevant to 7.12.4 and 7.12.7 may imply the use of sketches or figures, these can
be placed in another specific section of the manual. It is considered that the dimensions in sketches can
be indicated with the font dimensions more suitable for the proportion of the sketch.
2013/07 - Subclause 21.1 Brussels, November 2013, CLC/TC 61(SEC)2024 + CH NC comments
Sub-clause 21.1 is applicable to any parts of the enclosure irrespective of the material they are made of.
Damage to the finish, ragged or sharp surfaces, small dents are not examined according to sub-clause
22.14, as this sub-clause is only dealing to the state of the appliance in normal use.
2014/03 - Subclause 22.17 Stresa, June 2014, CLC/TC 61(SEC)2083
Spacers intended to prevent the appliance from overheating walls shall be fixed so that it is not possible
to remove them from the outside of the appliance by hand or by means of a screwdriver or a spanner.
Built-in appliances are not evaluated for this clause, since the installation is covered by 7.12.4.
2006/02 - Subclause 22.44 Milano, November 2006, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1586+A
Brussels, June 2010, CLC/TC 61(SEC)1797
The wording “not …decorated like a toy” does not mean to put on a normal enclosure stickers or having
enclosures marked to represent animals or flowers or representing cars, or trains, or ball.
The meaning is that household appliances can be decorated to make them more attractive when the
buying is decided but not to have them considered as toys to play with.
NOTE See also the LVD/ADCO recommendation “LVD ADCO Recommendation regarding Child-Appealing
Household Appliances - November 2008”, available under the link
http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/sectors/electrical/files/adcorecommendations_childapp_en.pdf.
2014/04 – Subclauses 24.2, 25.1 Stresa, June 2014, CLC/TC 61(SEC)2083
The plug connector as defined in 3.101 of EN 60320-2-3 shown in the picture is not acceptable according
to subclauses 25.1 and 25.3, since it is not to be considered an appliance inlet. The definition of
appliance inlet is given in 3.2.3 of EN 60320-1.

2011/12 – Subclause 25.7 Malta, December 2011, CLC/TC 61(IT)0278/DC
Cable 03RNH2-F, not harmonized at CENELEC level but covered by a testing schedule developed by EU
certification bodies, or a harmonized cable with similar characteristics, can be used for appliances for
which 05RNH2-F is allowed.
2013/01 – Subclause 22.12 Dublin, June 2013, TC 61/DE0623/INF
Other parts that are intended to be detached during use, maintenance and cleaning (examples are
batteries, battery covers, lids, attachments, steam nozzles) are not considered to be “similar parts”.
5 EN 60335-2-3:2002/A11:2010, Electric irons
2011/02 – Table Z101 Brussels, June 2011, Requests of interpretation from FR NC
The meaning of the sentence “However, as it is adjacent to the functional surface and may become hot
through conduction, its temperature will be in the range between the functional and a touchable surface”
in the second dotted item of footnote a) is that, for footnote a) also the following surface “any part of the
surface surrounding the adjacent surface plus 25 mm or, where no adjacent surface exists, the soleplate
of an iron plus 25 mm” shall not be taken into account.
2011/03 – Table Z101 Brussels, June 2011, Requests of interpretation from FR NC
The precision metallic tip of an electric iron is considered as a functional surface. See photographs below
for more information.
Functional ironing tip
Precision metallic tip for best ironing patch pockets and collar of shirts

2014/08, Subclause 22.Z101 Brussels, November 2014, Requests of interpretation from GB NC
of EN 60335-2-3: 2002+A11:2010 alignment with subclause 25.101 of EN 60335-2-15
The length of the supply cord is measured between the entry into the plug and the point where the cord
enters the appliance. Cord guards are considered to be part of the supply cord.
6 EN 60335-2-5:2003, Dishwashers
DECISION SHEET Date
1998-02-19
Standard EN 60335-2-5:2003 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
19.101 7 4.5.3.5 (SEC)22/92
19.101 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Abnormal operation
Problem
When should defects be applied ?
Decision
At the most unfavourable time. Defects may be introduced at any time during the cycle.
Comment
CLC/TC 61 decision of February 1993.
rd
This decision has been updated after the 23 OSM/HA meeting.
DECISION SHEET Date
1998-02-19
Standard EN 60335-2-5:2003 OSM/HA
(Sub)clause Meeting Agenda item Document Exp. date
19 7 4.5.3.7 (SEC)24/92
19 23 6.4.2 (SEC)05/09
Subject
Abnormal operation
Problem
Are door interlock switches short-circuited ?
Decision
Door interlock switches are not short-circuited.
Comment
Opening and short-circuiting of components a
...