Copper and copper alloys - Plumbing fittings - Part 2: Fittings with compression ends for use with copper tubes

This European Standard specifies materials and test requirements for fittings of copper and copper alloys with or without plating or coating.

Kupfer und Kupferlegierungen - Fittings - Teil 2: Klemmverbindungen für Kupferrohre

Cuivre et alliages de cuivre - Raccords - Partie 2 : Raccords à compression pour tubes en cuivre

La présente Norme européenne spécifie les matériaux et exigences d'essai concernant les raccords en cuivre et alliage de cuivre avec ou sans placage ou revêtement.
La présente partie de l'EN 1254 spécifie les raccordements à compression compris entre 6 mm et 108 mm destinés à l’assemblage des tubes en cuivre utilisés dans l'acheminement de l'eau chaude, froide ou tiède, les systèmes de chauffage ou de refroidissement ou les systèmes au gaz naturel et au gaz de pétrole liquéfié (GPL).
Les températures de fonctionnement admises et les pressions maximales de service sont également établies.
La présente norme est applicable aux raccords de compression pour l'assemblage des tubes suivants :
   Tubes en cuivre conformément à l'EN 1057 ;
   Tubes en cuivre pré-isolés conformément à l'EN 13349.
Les raccords peuvent également être adaptés à l'assemblage d'autres tubes, à condition que le raccord à compression qui accompagne le tube en question soit conforme aux exigences de la présente norme.
Les raccords peuvent être composés d'une combinaison de différents types d'extrémité spécifiés dans la présente norme EN 1254, ou dans d'autres normes, à condition qu'ils soient adaptés au fluide/gaz qu'ils acheminent.
La norme établit un système de désignation des raccords.

Baker in bakrove zlitine - Fitingi - 2. del: Fitingi za spajanje z bakrenimi cevmi s stiskanjem

General Information

Status
Not Published
Current Stage
5098 - Decision to abandon - Formal Approval
Start Date
03-Mar-2010
Completion Date
03-Mar-2010

Relations

Buy Standard

Draft
prEN 1254-2:2007
English language
55 pages
sale 10% off
Preview
sale 10% off
Preview
e-Library read for
1 day

Standards Content (Sample)

SLOVENSKI STANDARD
oSIST prEN 1254-2:2007
01-junij-2007
Baker in bakrove zlitine - Fitingi - 2. del: Fitingi za spajanje z bakrenimi cevmi s
stiskanjem
Copper and copper alloys - Plumbing fittings - Part 2: Fittings with compression ends for
use with copper tubes
Kupfer und Kupferlegierungen - Fittings - Teil 2: Klemmverbindungen für Kupferrohre
Ta slovenski standard je istoveten z: prEN 1254-2
ICS:
23.040.40 Kovinski fitingi Metal fittings
77.120.30 Baker in bakrove zlitine Copper and copper alloys
oSIST prEN 1254-2:2007 en;de
2003-01.Slovenski inštitut za standardizacijo. Razmnoževanje celote ali delov tega standarda ni dovoljeno.

---------------------- Page: 1 ----------------------
EUROPEAN STANDARD
DRAFT
prEN 1254-2
NORME EUROPÉENNE
EUROPÄISCHE NORM
May 2007
ICS 23.040.40 Will supersede EN 1254-2:1998
English Version
Copper and copper alloys - Plumbing fittings - Part 2: Fittings
with compression ends for use with copper tubes
Kupfer und Kupferlegierungen - Fittings - Teil 2:
Klemmverbindungen für Kupferrohre
This draft European Standard is submitted to CEN members for enquiry. It has been drawn up by the Technical Committee CEN/TC 133.
If this draft becomes a European Standard, CEN members are bound to comply with the CEN/CENELEC Internal Regulations which
stipulate the conditions for giving this European Standard the status of a national standard without any alteration.
This draft European Standard was established by CEN in three official versions (English, French, German). A version in any other language
made by translation under the responsibility of a CEN member into its own language and notified to the CEN Management Centre has the
same status as the official versions.
CEN members are the national standards bodies of Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland,
France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal,
Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and United Kingdom.
Recipients of this draft are invited to submit, with their comments, notification of any relevant patent rights of which they are aware and to
provide supporting documentation.
Warning : This document is not a European Standard. It is distributed for review and comments. It is subject to change without notice and
shall not be referred to as a European Standard.
EUROPEAN COMMITTEE FOR STANDARDIZATION
COMITÉ EUROPÉEN DE NORMALISATION
EUROPÄISCHES KOMITEE FÜR NORMUNG
Management Centre: rue de Stassart, 36  B-1050 Brussels
© 2007 CEN All rights of exploitation in any form and by any means reserved Ref. No. prEN 1254-2:2007: E
worldwide for CEN national Members.

---------------------- Page: 2 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
Contents Page
Foreword.4
Introduction .5
1 Scope .6
2 Normative references .6
3 Definitions .7
4 Types.9
5 Operating temperatures and operating pressures.9
6 Requirements.10
6.1 General.10
6.2 Materials .10
6.3 Minimum bore area.11
6.4 Tolerance for the alignment of the fitting ends .12
6.5 Design and manufacture.13
7 Evaluation of conformity.13
7.1 General.13
7.2 Type testing.14
7.3 Factory production control (FPC) .15
8 Test requirements and parameters.17
8.1 Initial type testing .17
8.2 Factory production control system .21
9 Designation .22
10 Marking .23
10.1 General.23
10.2 Type 2 and 3 fittings .23
10.3 Type 1 and 3 fittings produced from dezincification resistant copper-zinc alloys.23
11 Documentation.24
11.1 Declaration of conformity .24
11.2 User instructions .24
Annex A (normative) Test method for leaktightness of joints with metallic tube under internal
hydrostatic pressure .25
Annex B (normative) Test method for leaktightness of joints with metallic tube under internal
pneumatic pressure.27
Annex C (normative) Test method for leaktightness under internal hydrostatic pressure whilst
subjected to bending of joints with metallic tube .29
Annex D (normative) Test method for resistance to pull out of joints with metallic tube.31
Annex E (normative) Test method for the resistance of joints with metallic tube to temperature
cycling.33
Annex F (normative) Test method for the resistance of joints to operating temperature.36
Annex G (normative) Test method for the resistance of joints with metallic tube to pressure
cycling.38
Annex H (normative) Test method for leaktightness of joints with metallic tube under vacuum .40
Annex I (normative) Test method for the resistance of joints to high temperature.42
Annex J (normative) Method for the determination of the resistance to stress corrosion .43
2

---------------------- Page: 3 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
Annex K (normative) Test method for fittings bodies with as-cast microstructure or fabricated by
welding or brazing under pressure .44
Annex L (normative) Method for the determination of the mean depth of dezincification .46
Annex ZA (informative) Clauses of this European Standard addressing the provisions of the EU
Construction Products Directive (CPD) 89/106/EEC.48
Bibliography.55

3

---------------------- Page: 4 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
Foreword
This document (prEN 1254-2:2007) has been prepared by Technical Committee CEN/TC 133 “Copper and
copper alloys”, the secretariat of which is held by DIN.
This document is currently submitted to the CEN Enquiry.
This document will supersede EN 1254-2:1998.
Within its programme of work, Technical Committee CEN/TC 133 requested CEN/TC 133/WG 8 "Fittings" to
prepare the revision of the following standard:
EN 1254-2:1998, Copper and copper alloys — Plumbing fittings — Part 2: Fittings with compression ends for
use with copper tubes
This document has been prepared under a mandate given to CEN by the European Commission and the
European Free Trade Association, and supports essential requirements of EU Directives.
For relationship with EU Directives, see informative Annex ZA, which is an integral part of this document.
In comparison with the first edition of EN 1254-2:1998, the following significant technical changes were made:
 harmonization of the standard to the Construction Product Directive (CPD);
 introduction of new definitions: “maximum operating pressure (MOP)”, "durably marked”, "permanently
marked", “initial type test (ITT)”, and “factory production control (FPC)”;
 due to the process of harmonization to the CPD, introduction of three new characteristics in Clause 6
Material characteristics inherent to copper material which are not to be tested;
 text in Clause 7 Evaluation of conformity added due to the process of harmonization to the CPD;
 for permanent and durable markings, specification of their applicability in Clause 9 Marking;
 improved presentation of test methods; in annexes;
 due to the process of harmonization to the CPD, introduction of Annex ZA.
This Standard for fittings of copper and copper alloys for joining metallic tubes or plastics pipes is in seven parts.
The other parts are:
— Part 1: Fittings with ends for capillary soldering or capillary brazing to copper tubes
— Part 3: Fittings with compression ends for use with plastics pipes
— Part 4: Fittings with threaded end connections
— Part 5: Fittings with short ends for capillary brazing to copper tubes
— Part 6: Fittings with push-fit ends
— Part 7: Fittings with press ends for metallic tubes
4

---------------------- Page: 5 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
Introduction
Products in conformity with this part of this standard are considered suitable for drinking water applications
subject to either:
1) compliance with any national regulations in the country of intended destination, or
2) compliance in due course with the proposed European Acceptance Scheme (EAS) that will introduce
common EU requirements for testing for fitness for contact with drinking water. When the EAS is imple-
mented, this part of the Standard shall have added to it a special Annex (Z/EAS) to incorporate the provi-
sions of the EC Mandate M 136 and 1) will no longer be applicable.
This part of this European Standard provides the basis for the assessment of a manufacturer’s production
process for products manufactured in accordance with this standard. The assessment could be based on ini-
tial and continuing surveillance of the factory production control system, which could be concurrent with an
assessment of the manufacturer’s quality management system against EN ISO 9001.
Regulatory marking and the means by which regulatory marking is applied is dealt with in Annex ZA.
5

---------------------- Page: 6 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
1 Scope
This European Standard specifies materials and test requirements for fittings of copper and copper alloys with
or without plating or coating.
This part of EN 1254 specifies compression end connections in the size range 6 mm to 108 mm for the
purpose of joining copper tubes intended for use in hot or cold or combined hot and cold water, heating and
cooling systems, natural gas and liquefied petroleum gas systems.
Permissible operating temperatures and maximum operating pressures are also established.
This standard is applicable to compression fittings for joining the following tubes:
Copper tubes to EN 1057;
Pre-insulated copper tubes to EN 13349.
Fittings may also be suitable for joining other tubes provided the compression fitting joint with the specified
tube meets the requirements of this standard.
Fittings may comprise a combination of end types, specified in this standard, EN 1254, or other standards,
providing they are suitable for the fluid/gas being conveyed.
The standard establishes a designation system for the fittings.
2 Normative references
The following referenced documents are indispensable for the application of this document. For dated refer-
ences, only the edition cited applies. For undated references, the latest edition of the referenced document
(including any amendments) applies.
EN 437, Test gases — Test pressures — Appliance categories
EN 549, Elastomeric materials for seals and diaphragms for gas appliances and gas systems
EN 681-1, Elastomeric seals — Materials requirements for pipe joint seals used in water and drainage appli-
cations — Part 1: Vulcanised rubber
EN 682, Elastomeric seals — Materials requirements for seals used in pipes and fittings carrying gas and
hydrocarbon fluids
EN 1057, Copper and copper alloys — Seamless, round copper tubes for water and gas in sanitary and heating
applications
EN 1254-1, Copper and copper alloys — Plumbing fittings — Part 1: Fittings with ends for capillary soldering or
capillary brazing to copper tubes
EN 1254-3, Copper and copper alloys — Plumbing fittings — Part 3: Fittings with compression ends for use with
plastics pipes
EN 1254-4, Copper and copper alloys — Plumbing fittings — Part 4: Fittings combining other end connections
with capillary or compression ends
EN 1254-5, Copper and copper alloys — Plumbing fittings — Part 5: Fittings with short ends for capillary brazing
to copper tubes
6

---------------------- Page: 7 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
prEN 1254-6, Copper and copper alloys — Plumbing fittings — Part 6: Fittings with push-fit ends
prEN 1254-7, Copper and copper alloys — Plumbing fittings — Part 7: Fittings with press ends for metallic
tubes
EN 1655, Copper and copper alloys — Declarations of conformity
EN 1775, Gas supply — Gas pipework for buildings — Maximum operating pressure ≤ 5 bar — Functional
recommendations
EN 13349, Copper and copper alloys — Pre-insulated copper tubes with solid covering
EN 14905, Copper and copper alloys — Plumbing fittings — Recommended practice for the installation of
copper and copper alloy plumbing fittings
EN ISO 6509:1995, Corrosion of metals and alloys — Determination of dezincification resistance of brass
(ISO 6509:1981)
EN ISO 9001:2000, Quality management systems — Requirements
ISO 6957:1988, Copper alloys — Ammonia test for stress corrosion resistance
ISO 9924-1, Rubber and rubber products — Determination of the composition of vulcanizates and uncured
compounds by thermogravimetry — Part 1: Butadiene, ethylene-propylene copolymer and terpolymer, iso-
butene-isoprene, isoprene and styrene-butadiene rubbers
NOTE Informative references to documents used in the preparation of this standard, and cited at the appropriate
places in the text, are listed in the Bibliography.
3 Definitions
For the purposes of this standard, the following definitions apply.
3.1
plumbing fitting
device used in a tube system for the purpose of connecting the tubes either to each other or to a component
part of the system
3.2
compression end
end in which the joint is made by the compression of a ring or sleeve on the outside wall of the tube
3.2.1
compression end, Type A
end that requires no preparation of the ends of the tube other than that they are cut square and deburred, or
chamfered when specified, and in which the joint is made by the compression of a ring or sleeve onto the out-
side wall of the tube with or without additional sealing elements and with or without an internal tube support
NOTE The sealing element may be metallic or non-metallic.
3.2.2
compression end, Type B
end that requires forming of the tube at its end, and in which the joint is made by compressing the formed por-
tion of the tube against the formed end of the fitting or a loose ring or sleeve within the fitting/tube
7

---------------------- Page: 8 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
3.3
reducer (compression end for copper tube)
component or components used to enable a compression end to connect tube of a smaller nominal diameter
than the nominal diameter of the fitting end
3.4
adaptor fitting
fitting combining more than one type of end
NOTE For details of other ends, see the relevant parts of this standard or other standards.
3.5
nominal diameter
nominal diameter of a fitting end expressed as the nominal outside diameter of the connecting tube
3.6
fuel gas
combustible gases which are gaseous at 15 °C and 1 013 mbar and are generally odorized for safety reasons,
are commonly referred to as manufactured gas, natural gas or liquefied petroleum gases (LPG)
NOTE They are also referred to as first, second or third family gases (see EN 437:1993, Table 1).
3.7
maximum operating pressure
MOP
maximum operating pressure at which pipework can be operated under normal operating conditions
3.8
durably marked
marked in such a way that the marking will remain readable at least up to the time of commissioning of the
installation
NOTE Marked e.g. by ink marking.
3.9
permanently marked
marked in such a way that the marking will remain readable up to the end of the life of the installation
NOTE Marked e.g. by stamping, etching or engraving.
3.10
initial type test
ITT
complete set of tests or other procedures described in the technical specification, determining the perform-
ance of samples of products representative of the product type
NOTE Other procedures e.g. calculation.
3.11
factory production control
FPC
means by which a manufacturer ensures that the performances declared by the manufacturer (obtained from
ITT) continue to be valid for all subsequent products
8

---------------------- Page: 9 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
4 Types
There are three types of compression fitting ends depending on the medium with which they are suitable for
use, as shown in Table 1.
Table 1 — Types of fitting ends
Type Medium used
1 Water
2 Fuel gas
3 Water and fuel gas

5 Operating temperatures and operating pressures
Operating temperatures and operating pressures for assembled joints shall not exceed the values in Tables 2,
3 or 4 according to classification and medium.
Table 2 — Operating temperatures and operating pressures for Type 1 and Type 3 fitting ends with
metallic sealing elements when used with water
Operating
Fitting size and maximum water operating pressure (MOP)
temperature
bar
°C
6 mm to 15 mm > 15 mm to 28 mm > 28 mm to 54 mm > 54 mm to 108 mm
95 25 16 13 10
NOTE 1 Certain designs of compression fitting ends are suitable for use at temperature/pressure ratings outside
those given in this table. For such applications, the advice of the manufacturer should be sought.
NOTE 2 To allow for system malfunctions, fittings shall be capable of temporary excursions up to a temperature of
110 °C at a pressure of 10 bar.

Table 3 — Operating temperatures and operating pressures for Type 2 and Type 3 fitting ends when
used with gas
Maximum operating pressure for nominal diameters
Operating temperature
from 6 mm up to and including 54 mm
°C
bar
MOP 5 MOP 1
– 20 to + 70 5 1

9

---------------------- Page: 10 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
6 Requirements
6.1 General
Fittings, including reducers, shall conform to the requirements of 6.2 to 6.5
6.2 Materials
6.2.1 General
Fittings bodies shall be made from copper or copper alloys selected from materials either:
 specified in European copper and copper alloy product standards; or
 registered by CEN/TC 133;
provided that the fittings manufactured from them meet the functional requirements of this standard.
NOTE Some of the standardized coppers and copper alloys commonly used for the manufacture of fittings are shown
in Table 4. Details of registered alloys can be obtained from the CEN/TC 133 Secretariat.
Table 4 — Examples of commonly used materials
Material designation
Standard
Symbol Number
Cu-DHP CW024A EN 12449
CuSn5Zn5Pb5-C CC491K EN 1982
CuZn36Pb2As CW602N EN 12164
CuZn39Pb3 CW614N EN 12164
CuZn40Pb2 CW617N EN 12165
CuZn33Pb2-C CC750S EN 1982
CuZn15As-C CC760S EN 1982
NOTE This table do not constitute an exhaustive list.

Other components can be made from metallic or non-metallic materials, provided that they do not prevent the
fitting meeting the functional requirements of this standard and do not cause degradation of the connected
tube.
Non-metallic sealing elements for Type 1 and Type 3 fitting ends for water applications shall conform to the
requirements for elastomeric materials in EN 681-1 and Table 5 of this standard.
10

---------------------- Page: 11 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
Table 5 — Non metallic sealing elements when used in Type 1 or Type 3 fittings — additional
requirements and tests
No. Test procedures
Tear strength in accordance with EN 681-1, Table 3.
1 This requirement applies to all elastomeric sealing materials for water applications.
Minimum tear strength: > 20 N
Thermogravimetric analysis for identity testing of elastomeric materials for water applications.
The TGA is carried out in accordance with ISO 9924-1.
2
Frequency of test — the TGA shall be carried out at the initial type testing stage to produce the
master graph. Further analysis will be made to compare the production to the master curve at a
frequency of once per year thereafter.

Non-metallic sealing elements for Type 2 and Type 3 fitting ends for use with gas shall conform to the
requirements for elastomeric materials in EN 549 and Table 6 of this standard.
Table 6 — Sealing elements for Type 2 and Type 3 fittings — additional requirements and tests
Test procedures
Ozone resistance testing and requirements in accordance with EN 549, 7.8 and 6.2, Table 3.
Requirement — no cracks
Material identity.
Infrared spectra.
The elastomer and the seal shall meet EN 549, Annex B.2 requirements for infrared spectra.
Frequency of test — the test shall be carried out at the initial type testing stage to produce the master
graph. Further analysis will be made to compare the production to the master graph at a frequency of once
per year thereafter.

Products intended for use in drinking water applications shall meet the requirements of the European Accep-
tance Scheme (EAS).
In the absence of the EAS, national requirements apply.
6.2.2 Safety in case of fire — Reaction to fire
Products which consist of copper or copper alloys are products/materials that do not require to be tested for
reaction to fire (i.e. products/materials of Class A.1 according to Commission Decision 96/603/EC, as
amended 2000/605/EC).
6.2.3 Properties at high temperature
The mechanical properties of products which consist of copper or copper alloys at temperatures encountered
in heating networks are not reduced significantly; for example, no adjustment to maximum admissible stress in
pressure calculations would be necessary for temperatures from ambient up to 110 °C.
Elastomeric seals shall conform to the requirements of EN 681-1, Table 3 for continuous temperatures up to
110 °C.
6.3 Minimum bore area
The minimum cross-sectional area of the bore through each fitting, excluding any internal support, shall be not
less than the theoretical minimum area of the bore given in Table 7, except that for unequal-ended or adaptor fit-
tings with ends specified in EN 1254, or other standards, the smallest diameter shall apply provided that this di-
ameter does not restrict other outlets.
11

---------------------- Page: 12 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
Table 7 — Minimum bore diameter
Dimensions in millimetres
Nominal diameter
Minimum bore diameter
D
  6  4,0
  8  6,0
 10  7,0
 12  9,0
 14 10,0
 14,7
11,0
 15
 16 12,0
 18 14,0
 21
18,0
 22
 25 21,0
 27,4
23,0
 28
 34
29,0
 35
 40 35,0
 40,5
36,0
 42
 53,6
47,0
 54
 64 55,0
 66,7 57,0
 70 60,0
 76,1 65,0
 80 68,0
 88,9 76,0
108 92,0

6.4 Tolerance for the alignment of the fitting ends
The alignment of the ends of the fitting shall be within 2° of the specified axis.
12

---------------------- Page: 13 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
6.5 Design and manufacture
Joints with seals shall be designed to meet the expected lifetime of a building or to the first expected renova-
tion period of the building.
The tightness of the joint, on the grounds of actual technical knowledge, is presumed to be capable of main-
taining required performance over a period of at least 50 years under the influence of foreseeable actions and
normal maintenance to fulfil the essential requirements, if the joint itself is in conformity with the requirements
of this standard.
6.5.1 Compression fittings, Type A
Compression fittings, Type A, are suitable for use with copper tubes to EN 1057 in all temper conditions.
NOTE Compression fittings, Type A, will possibly require an internal support when used with R220 (annealed) copper
tube and the manufacturer’s advice should be sought.
6.5.2 Compression fittings, Type B
Compression fittings, Type B, are suitable for use with R220 (annealed) or R250 (half-hard) copper tube to
EN 1057.
NOTE Compression fittings, Type B, may be suitable for use with R290 (hard) copper tube and the manufacturer’s
advice should be sought.
6.5.3 Tube abutment
Fitting ends are usually manufactured with an abutment to limit tube insertion.
Fittings may be produced for special purposes, particularly useful for repairs, where the fitting ends do not in-
corporate abutments, allowing for the fitting to slide along the tube.
6.5.4 Tightening systems
Shapes for transmitting tightening torques are required on compression nuts and straight bodies.
6.5.5 Surface condition
Fittings shall be clean and free from sharp edges.
6.5.6 Plated or coated surfaces
Requirements for plated or coated surfaces shall be the subject of agreement between the purchaser and the
manufacturer and shall not impair the performance of the joint.
7 Evaluation of conformity
7.1 General
The conformity of plumbing fittings to the requirements of this standard and with the stated values shall be
demonstrated by:
 initial type testing;
 factory production control by the manufacturer, including product assessment.
13

---------------------- Page: 14 ----------------------
prEN 1254-2:2007 (E)
For the purposes of testing, plumbing fittings may be grouped into families, where it is considered that the se-
lected property/properties is/are common to all the fittings within that family.
7.2 Type testing
7.2.1 Initial type testing
7.2.1.1 General
An initial type test is the complete set of tests or other procedures, determining the performance of samples of
products representative of the product type.
Initial type testing shall be performed to show conformity with this standard.
7.2.1.2 Requirements
All requirements in Clause 6 and Subclause 8.1 shall be subject to initial type testing. The metallic material
characteristics in Subclauses 6.2.2 and 6.2.3 do not need testing because:
 reaction to fire – copper and copper alloys are class A.1 according to Commission Decision 96/603/EC;
 properties at high temperature – mechanical properties are not reduced significantly at temperatures con-
cerned.
 release of regulated (dangerous included) substances — copper or copper alloys standardized or regis-
tered by CEN/TC 133 involve no regulated (dangerous included) substances.
7.2.1.3 Use of historical data
Tests previously performed on fittings of the same design and dimension in accor
...

Questions, Comments and Discussion

Ask us and Technical Secretary will try to provide an answer. You can facilitate discussion about the standard in here.